Bulletin
British Museum
(Natural History)
VOLUME 20 NUMBER 2 20 DECEMBER 1990
The Bulletin of the British Museum (Natural History), instituted in 1949, is issued in
four scientific series, Botany, Entomology, Geology (incorporating Mineralogy) and
Zoology, and an Historical series.
The Botany Series is edited in the Museum's Department of Botany
Keeper of Botany: Dr S. Blackmore
Editor of Bulletin: Dr R. Huxley
Assistant Editor: Dr A. J. Harrington
Assistant Editor: Mrs M. J. West
Papers in the Bulletin are primarily the results of research carried out on the unique and ever-
growing collections of the Museum, both by the scientific staff and by specialists from elsewhere
who make use of the Museum's resources. Many of the papers are works of reference that will
remain indispensable for years to come.
A volume contains about 256 pages, made up of two numbers: published Spring and Autumn.
Subscriptions may be placed for one or more of the series on an annual basis. Individual numbers
and back numbers can be purchased and a Bulletin catalogue, by series, is available. Orders and
enquiries should be sent to:
Sales Department,
Natural History Museum Publications,
British Museum (Natural History),
Cromwell Road,
London SW7 5BD
Telephone: 07 1-938-9386
Telex: 929437 NH PUBS G
Fax: 07 1-938-8709
World List abbreviation: Bull. Br. Mus. nat. Hist. (Bot.)
British Museum (Natural History), 1990
ISBN 565 08027 X Botany Series
ISSN 0068 - 2292 Vol 20(2), pp 1 53 - 237
British Museum (Natural History)
Cromwell Road
London S W7 5 BD Issued 20 December 1 990
Typeset by J & L Composition, Filey, N. Yorks.
Printed in Great Britain by Henry Ling Ltd., at the Dorset Press, Dorchester, Dorset
Bull. Br. Mus. nat. Hist (Bot.) 20(2): 153-168
Issued 20 December 1990
The marine algal flora of Namibia: its
distribution and affinities
BRITISH MUSEUM
[NATURAL IMSIORY)
14J
proem-no
GEORGE W. LAWSON_/ C
23 Sheffield Terrace, London W8 7NQ
RICHARD H. SIMONS
Department of Botany, University of Cape Town, Rondebosch, South Africa 7700
WILLIAM EDWIN ISAAC
20 Spraypoint Road, Blairgowrie, Victoria 3942, Australia
GENERAL
CONTENTS
Introduction 153
The Namibian coast and its environmental conditions 154
Patterns of littoral zonation 154
The phytogeographical status of the Namibian marine algal flora 161
Annotated list of species 164
References 167
SYNOPSIS. The coast of Namibia (South West Africa) which lies partly within and partly outside the tropics on the
south western Atlantic coast of Africa was visited and studied in July 1957. Littoral zonation at three main localities
(Liideritz, Elizabeth Bay, and Swakopmund) is briefly described, and an annotated list is presented of the 136
species of marine algae now known from Namibia, as well as of certain algae identified only to genus.
Phytogeographically, the marine algal flora of Namibia represents a northward extension of the flora of the western
coast of South Africa though somewhat depleted north of the tropic. The boundary between the Namibian flora and
the tropical flora of Angola is a sharp one and occurs at, or just north of, the political border of these two countries.
INTRODUCTION
This paper is a further development of reseach originally
undertaken as part of the survey of South African intertidal
plant ecology then being conducted by Professor William
Edwyn Isaac, of the Department of Botany, University of
Cape Town. Professor Isaac organized the Namibia field
excursion which took place during the southern winter of
1957, in which the participants were Professor W. E. Isaac,
Miss Judith Graves, Mr R. H. Simons, and Dr G. W.
Lawson. Use has already been made of the collections then
assembled in several studies and some of the species identi-
fied have been referred to in publications (e.g. John et al.,
1979; Lawson, 1978; Lawson & Price, 1969; Lawson et al.,
1975; Price et al., 1978, 1986, 1988; Silva, 1959; Simons, 1964,
1966, 1970). It is felt that, despite the time elapsed since the
completion of the field work, and despite the rather limited
nature of some of our ecological observations in the short
time available (which included two successive spring tide
periods), a more comprehensive account here attempted is of
value in view of the very small amount of work hitherto
published on the marine algae of the region and of the current
interest in it (see Hommersand, 1986).
The main object of the excursion was to provide data on
the composition, distribution, and zonation of the marine
algal flora of Namibia (then South West Africa), previously
much under-investigated from those points of view. The
reason for the lack of information is not far to seek. Along the
whole of the coast lies the formidable Namib desert making it
difficult to reach and extremely inhospitable. In fact, over-
land access is only practicable by the roads that have been
built to the few townships along the coast. The main acces-
sible areas are around the towns of Swakopmund (22 40' S)
and Walvis Bay in the centre and Liideritz (26 38' S), some
450 km further south. We also had the opportunity of visiting
Elizabeth ville, a relict town no longer inhabited but acces-
sible by road, a short distance south of Liideritz. Though the
total time available was approximately one month, because of
the great distances to be covered between centres and the
then indifferent nature of the roads, our main field work was
accomplished during about a week when we were based at
Swakopmund and a similar period based at Liideritz. From
the phycological point of view the coast of the Republic of
South Africa is relatively well-known, having been worked
over a considerable number of years (see Seagrief &
Troughton, 1973 and Seagrief, 1984). Isaac, (19376) has given
a description of the intertidal seaweed vegetation of the west
coast of South Africa from Lambert's Bay to the Cape of
Good Hope. He has also described zonation to the south-east
of the Cape of Good Hope (Isaac, 1949). Though the zonation
is similar to that on the west coast, east of Cape Town there
are some differences, especially in the sublittoral fringe. In a
later paper Isaac & Hewitt (1953) pointed out that the region
154
from Cape Point to Cape Agulhas is best regarded as an
extension of the west coast, if False Bay, which possesses
relatively higher sea temperatures, is excepted. It is from the
zoological point of view, however, that the most comprehen-
sive picture of the biogeographical distribution of intertidal
organisms in South Africa has been constructed. Stephenson
and his co-workers were actively engaged on these problems
between 1932 and 1937 and these studies were summarized by
Stephenson in three papers published in 1939, 1944, and
1948. One of the main conclusions that emerged from this
work was that there are three distinct faunas on South
African shores: an essentially sub-tropical fauna on the east
coast, a warm temperate fauna on the south coast, and a cold
temperate fauna on the west coast. There are, of course,
many examples of intergrading and overlapping between
these faunas. Stephenson indicated his belief that the same
situation was substantially true for the algae though it appears
from his diagrams (Stephenson, 1944) that the number of
species present only along the south coast is relatively small.
More recently Bolton (1986) has given a similar but fuller
analysis.
From the point of view of the present study it is the
distribution of the west coast flora that is most interesting. Its
southern limit, as indicated above, is approximately at Cape
Agulhas, but the northern limit is less certain, and the
establishment of that limit was one of the objectives of the
present survey. Stephenson and his co-workers did not pene-
trate into Namibia and their furthest northerly place studied
was the Port Nolloth region, south of the Orange river that
marks the coastal boundary between the Cape Province of
South Africa and Namibia.
Subsequent to our own work in Namibia, however, Penrith
& Kensley (1970a, 19706) and Kensley & Penrith (1980) have
also visited the area with much the same objectives as
ourselves. In their case the interest was mainly zoological and
algae were treated as subsidiary. Kensley & Penrith (1973)
were also able to study rocky shores at Mogamedes (Angola)
and surveys of the marine algae for that same region are
reported by Lawson et al. (1975) and John et al. (1981).
Information from all these sources, as well as from Wynne
(1986), is used in a later section when we attempt to assess the
biogeographical significance of our field work in Namibia.
LAWSON, SIMONS & ISAAC
Undoubtedly the most significant feature of the Namib
coast, as far as seaweeds is concerned, is that the Benguela
Current flows northwards along its length with the denser
waters of lower temperature closer inshore. The prevailing
southerly and south- easterly winds carry these surface waters
away from the coast and upwelling of water from 100-300 m
depths takes place at most times of the year (Anon., 1964).
This causes nutrient-rich waters of low temperature and
relatively low salinity to influence the coastal biota. Surface
temperatures as low as 10-15C in winter and 12-20C in
summer for this coast are on record (Anon., 1964), and Isaac
(1937a) points out that the average annual temperature at
Walvis Bay, just within the tropics, is as low as 16.1C. Bolton
(1986) includes 10 year averages of annual maximum and
minimum monthly temperatures for both Walvis Bay and
Liideritz. Any botanist visiting this area must be struck by the
contrast between the extreme paucity of the terrestrial vege-
tation on the hot and arid coastal plains and the relative
luxuriance of the marine vegetation.
According to Sverdrup, Fleming & Johnson (1942), the
effect of the Benguela Current is particularly marked as far
north as latitude 17; thus virtually the whole of the Namib
coast is included since the northern border at Kunene River
mouth is at 17 16' S. Somewhere near Cape Frio (18 30' S)
the Benguela Current begins to turn out westwards into the
Atlantic. More detailed accounts of the hydrography of the
region are given in, for example, Anon. (1963), Stephenson
& Stephenson (1972), and Richards et al. (1981), while
Shannon et al. (1987) describe a mobile front interfacing
Angolan waters and the Benguela System. Sand storms on
the coastal strip are frequent enough events, but far more
common and of greater significance to its desert life are the
'mist-rain' and chilling sea mists that blanket the coast during
darkness and early parts of the day (Anon., 1964: 77, 83).
These mists are more frequent in the north than in the south.
Thus, emersed shore life is perhaps very often shielded from
the worst effects of desiccation and overheating during the
early part of the mornings. One of the causes of this
condensation is the relatively low surface temperature of the
adjacent sea (Anon., 1964). Coastal humidity is relatively
high even in summer (certainly higher than at Cape Town)
and this, too, must have a protective role (Anon., 1964).
THE NAMIBIAN COAST AND ITS
ENVIRONMENTAL CONDITIONS
The long (approximately 1500 km) but relatively straight
coastline of Namibia (Fig. 1) lying between 17 16' S and 28
30' S is inhospitable, the Namib desert reaching directly to
the sea along much of its length. Considerable stretches
consist merely of wave-beaten beaches and are therefore
practically devoid of intertidal seaweed vegetation, though
broken rocky outcrops with more extensive areas of cliffs
occur at intervals; our observations have been limited to such
of these areas as we were able to reach. In general the coast is
exposed to the full force of the Atlantic rollers, but some
shelter from wave-action is found in places such as the natural
harbour at Liideritz and the artificial one at Swakopmund.
Tides are semi-diurnal and the amplitude is not great, vary-
ing most often from under 1.5 m (springs) to little more than
one metre (neaps). Exceptionally the range may be over 1.8 m.
PATTERNS OF LITTORAL ZONATION
In the following account we have used the littoral zonation
scheme of Lewis (1961). As faunal zonation is important in
Lewis' scheme we have, where necessary, added our own
limited observations on the vertical distribution of animals.
(a) The Liideritz area
At Liideritz we examined littoral rocks at three sites: firstly,
the recreational area adjacent to the town itself; secondly, at
Elizabeth Bay (visited through the courtesy of the regional
representative of Consolidated Diamond Mines) a 'ghost'
town about 30 km to the south of Liideritz, and at one time a
centre for diamond operations; lastly, Halifax Bay, on the
open coast about 8 km west of Liideritz.
i) Liideritz
This site is in the vicinity of the resort area. Since it is a bay
within a bay it is well protected from surf action, and waves
were never higher than about 0.5 m during our stay.
ape Frio ~
) and Kensley & Penrith
(1980) refer to what is almost certainly the same entity as Littorina punctata
Philippi. In our opinion, however, these animals and those also referred to as
Littorina punctata that commonly inhabit the littoral fringe in the Gulf of
Guinea are not identical and, to avoid confusion, we have tentatively retained
the original name provided.
LAWSON, SIMONS & ISAAC
species of the mixed red algal belt of the lower Eulittoral,
such as Champia lumbricalis, Gigartina stiriata, G. radula,
and geniculate and encrusting Corallinaceae, also extended
into the Sublittoral Fringe where they were joined by species
apparently restricted to that zone, such as Hypnea spp.
Hypnea spicifera was found only locally in the protected
shallows of the harbour. Gracilaria verrucosa occurred in the
drift, and its presence in quantity is reported by Rotmann
(1987).
ii) Elizabeth Bay
Very gently sloping rocks in the centre of the rather shallow
open bay were studied. Although the outermost rocks were
exposed to strong wave-action, those inshore were appreci-
ably sheltered but never as much as the rocks at Luderitz.
The Littoral Fringe
This level was occupied by rather large individuals of Littorina
knysnaensis, very common in some places and less frequent in
others. Porphyra capensis was present to some extent.
The Eulittoral
The upper part of this zone was occupied mostly by limpets
(Patella granularis), and barnacles were not observed at this
level. Porphyra capensis occurred sporadically.
Below the Porphyra belt but still within the limpet belt,
Aeodes orbitosa, associated with Splachnidium rugosum, was
commonly found. At this level Chordariopsis capensis was
also very frequent but mostly in small pools and often
accompanied by Scytosiphon lomentaria.
Algae overlapping with this Aeodes-Splachnidium belt
were Centroceras clavulatum, Caulacanthus ustulatus, and
occasional plants of Corallina, Ulva, and Codium. Below
these was a belt of Gunnarea capensis tubes, sometimes as
much as 0.30 m in thickness above the rock surface. Growing
on this were several algal species, notably Ceramium sp.,
Leathesia difformis, and Cladophora sp., the last-mentioned
sometimes carrying the Leathesia. It should be noted that a
second type of worm tube, probably a Pomatoleios, was
sometimes present. Much harder and smoother than Gunnarea,
it often supported coralline crusts or tufts of Gelidium
micropterum and occurred frequently mixed with mussels up
to the lower level of Aeodes.
Near the lower limit of the Gunnarea belt began a belt of
Champia lumbricalis, often epiphytized by Aristothamnion
collabens, which extended into the Sublittoral Fringe to form
an undergrowth to the kelps. Large limpets, often bearing
small barnacles, formed fairly distinct areas interspersed with
Gunnarea in the lower part of its belt.
The Sublittoral Fringe
This was dominated by Laminaria pallida and Laminaria
schinzii but Ecklonia maxima was present especially in pools
(Plate 1). Other plants commonly found were Pachymenia
carnosa, Gigartina stiriata, G. radula, and Champia lumbri-
calis. In addition there were patches of Petalonia debilis,
Centroceras clavulatum, Cladophora spp., and crustose coral-
lines. Animals included Patella granatina, often bearing small
barnacles, the red sponge Hymeniacidon perlevis (Montagu),
and the starfish Asterina exigua (Lam.). Some patches of
mussels were present but by no means enough to account for
the vast quantities of shells thrown up on nearby beaches.
Patella compressa L. and Polysiphonia virgata were found on
the stipes of cast-up Laminaria.
ALGAL FLORA OF NAMIBIA
157
Plate 1 Kelp beds of the sublittoral fringe exposed at low spring tides at Elizabeth Bay. Laminaria pallida, Laminaria schinzii, and Ecklonia
maxima are present.
iii) Halifax Bay
A very brief visit was made to Halifax Bay where there was a
considerable extent of rocky coast and low cliff. Despite some
protection from the offshore penguin-populated islands, wave
exposure was strong in this area. The species present, and
their distribution on the shore, were much more in accord
with the typical pattern of zonation found on the west coast of
South Africa. Several species not found at Liideritz itself
were conspicuous here. Splachnidium rugosum was fairly
common in the upper Eulittoral, whilst Ecklonia maxima was
abundant in the sublittoral kelp beds. This counteracted the
impression we had gained from our examination of the rocks
near Liideritz itself that a number of species characteristic of
the west coast flora of South Africa had already disappeared
at about the latitude of Liideritz, and indicated that the
sheltered conditions of the harbour itself were more likely to
be responsible for these apparent absences.
(b) The Swakopmund area
The most northerly locality visited was Swakopmund (22
40' S) just within the tropics. Intertidal zonation was ex-
amined on the concrete blocks of the harbour wall and at two
points south of the town where there were extensive outcrops
of beach rock. The contrast between the rich algal flora of
the intertidal region and the extremely barren desert lying
directly behind the beach was even more marked than at
Liideritz.
i) The harbour wall
The Littoral Fringe
This was occupied by Littorina knysnaensis, accompanied by
some Siphonaria capensis, though more of the latter were
found in the Eulittoral. Plants of Porphyra capensis, though
not extending as high as the snails, were scattered throughout
the intertidal.
The Eulittoral
The more wave-exposed south-western faces of the harbour
wall could be divided into two subzones, an upper one in
which the dominant animals were Chthamalus dentatus and
Patella granularis, and a lower one in which occurred dense
carpets of small specimens of the mussel Perna perna and
large limpets.
In the upper subzone, the main algae found were Chaeto-
morpha, which extended more or less throughout, with
Iridaea capensis and some Petalonia debilis in its lower part.
In the upper reaches of the lower Eulittoral subzone, Poly-
siphonia, mixed with occasional plants of Ulva and of Chylo-
cladia capensis, formed a marked belt. Iridaea capensis bridged
the upper and lower subzones. The lower part of the lower
158
LAWSON, SIMONS & ISAAC
Plate 2 Laminaria schinzii dominating the sublittoral fringe near the concrete pier at Swakopmund.
Plate 3 Porphyra capensis on sheltered rocks behind the concrete pier at Swakopmund.
ALGAL FLORA OF NAMIBIA
Eulittoral subzone was occupied by Chondria capensis down
to the beginning of the Laminaria belt.
The Sublittoral Fringe
Due to heavy wave-action it was not possible to investigate
this level except to note that it appeared to be dominated by
the hollow-stiped Laminaria schinzii (Plate 2).
ii) Sheltered rocks behind the pier
The algal distribution was very different here, being less
distinct due to the broken nature of the rocks; good shelter
from strong surf also meant that the algae were telescoped
into the lower part of the Eulittoral. Enteromorpha was a
conspicuous feature, sometimes accompanied by Vrospora
sp. on the upper parts of the rocks. Porphyra capensis
was also very common (Plate 3), though not attaining quite
the same height up the shore as did the green algae. Cyano-
phyceae were also spread over the rocks, especially in the
form of a blackish powdery covering. The animals most in
evidence were Littorina knysnaensis and mussels (Modiolus
sp.), though our collections also included Balanus algicola,
Siphonaria capensis Quoy & Gaimard, and Patella granularis.
iii) Rocks south of Swakopmund
Our study of two fairly extensive and irregular outcrops of
gently-sloping rock, interrupting the sandy beaches, yielded
the following information.
The Littoral Fringe
This zone was present only where the rocks stood high
enough to accommodate it. Littorina knysnaensis was again
159
the dominant organism though it occurred also well down into
at least the middle of the Eulittoral zone. Porphyra capensis
was present in fairly large quantity, forming a narrow band
which did not appear to extend downwards as at some other
localities; not all samples taken could be attributed with
certainty to P. capensis since there were puzzling variants,
especially among the smaller forms; in particular we draw
attention to a small form with a distinctive rounded margin
(Plate 4), possibly an undescribed species. We also collected
Siphonaria sp. and a black and white limpet from the Porphyra
belt; at a somewhat lower level small plants of Viva were
present, mainly in depressions.
The Eulittoral
Barnacles and the small brownish Patella granularis with
some Littorina knysnaensis occupied the upper portion of this
zone; algae were few but included some Chaetomorpha,
mostly confined to shallow pools, and scattered small plants
of Viva.
Near the middle a subzone was discernable; mussels began
to replace barnacles, especially on the somewhat more
exposed parts where the former were generally rather larger;
Patella granularis, however, extended down into the mussel
subzone, where it was joined by some of the larger limpet
species. The upper limit of mussels and large limpets marked
the beginning of a much greater algal cover in the upper part
of the subzone (Plate 5), forming a distinct girdle of red algae
of which Caulacanthus ustulatus and Gymnogongrus glomera-
tus were the chief components with Nothogenia erinacea,
Plate 4 Plants of a small form of Porphyra found at Swakopmund.
160
LAWSON, SIMONS & ISAAC
-__ ~
Plate 5 The Eulittoral zone on rocks south of Swakopmund. Note that the upper part is very arid and practically devoid of algae, whereas the
lower part is covered by a dense mat of mixed algae including Caulacanthus ustulatus, Gymnogongrus glomeratus, and Centroceras davulatum.
Chylocladia capensis, Acrosorium maculatum, and much
Centroceras davulatum, which often occurred epiphytically
on the Caulacanthus.
Below this Caulacanthus-Gymnogongrus girdle was an-
other slightly less distinct belt dominated by Chondria capen-
sis, but including Pterosiphonia doiophylla, Ralfsia expansa,
Cladophora spp.,and, continuing into the Sublittoral, genicu-
late and crustose corallines.
The lowermost parts of the Eulittoral bore, in addition, a
number of larger red algae, perhaps representing elements of
the Sublittoral Fringe flora though rising above the Laminaria
level. They included species of Plocamium, such as P. cornu-
tum and P. rigidum, as well as the large fleshy fronds of
Pachymenia carnosa. (Plate 6) and Aeodes orbitosa (Plate 7).
The Sublittoral Fringe
This final zone was dominated by Laminaria schinzii but
included many of the algae found in the lower parts of the
Eulittoral corallines, Plocamium spp., and Pachymenia,
which together formed an undergrowth to the kelps. We did
not find Ecklonia maxima. The dominance of L. schinzii was
also indicated by the large quantity of this species thrown up
on nearby beaches.
c) General comments
The general features of algal zonation in the Liideritz area are
similar to those of the South African coast as described by
Isaac (1937b). Both areas have an upper Porphyra belt. This
is followed downwards by a Nothogenia belt, which at
Liideritz consists of N. ovalis, though this belt did not seem to
be represented at Elizabeth Bay. An Aeodes orbitosa belt was
also present at both Liideritz and at Elizabeth Bay. Aeodes
was accompanied by Splachnidium rugosum and Chordariop-
sis capensis. Bifurcaria brassicaeformis was apparently al-
together absent from Namibia. A Champia lumbricalis belt,
accompanied by species of Gigartina and Iridaea capensis, at
Liideritz was also present at Elizabeth Bay; Iridaea thus
appears to be somewhat lower on the shore here than further
south where it occurs in the Aeodes belt. Finally, a kelp belt is
present. at all localities, with Laminaria pallida and a hollow-
stiped form identified as L. schinzii found everywhere. One
of us (R.H.S.) has established that similar hollow forms
dominate the sublittoral as far south as Cape Columbine, the
western headland of St. Helena Bay about 120 km north of
Cape Town. Ecklonia maxima was also present at all locali-
ties, except for the sheltered shores at Liideritz, but usually as
a small plant. Where present, epiphytes seemed to prefer
Ecklonia maxima to Laminaria schinzii; Laminaria pallida
was usually without epiphytes. On the west coast of South
Africa, Suhria vittata occurs mostly associated with Ecklonia
maxima but in the Liideritz region it was often found on rocks
as well as on limpets in the intertidal.
Northwards, at Swakopmund, the situation was noticeably
different. The algal belts appeared to be narrower and lower
ALGAL FLORA OF NAMIBIA
161
Plate 6 Pachymenia carnosa growing on rocks just south of Swakopmund.
on the shore in this area than they were further south. Both
the Porphyra and the Nothogenia belts were present, at least
on the rocks south of Swakopmund. The Aeodes belt was not
represented here though Iridaea capensis was recorded from
the harbour wall at an appropriate level. Isaac's Champia-
Gigartina belt was much modified: Champia lumbricalis was
present in limited quantity, but the larger species of Gigartina
(G. stiriata, G. radula, and G. scutellata) were not found at
all. Finally, in the kelp bed Ecklonia maxima had, so far as
we could ascertain, completely disappeared and Laminaria
schinzii, rather than L. pallida, appeared to be dominant.
THE PHYTOGEOGRAPHICAL STATUS OF
THE NAMIBIAN MARINE ALGAL FLORA
The biogeographical status of the marine flora and fauna of
the western coast of southern Africa has been a somewhat
controversial topic since the biota have been regarded by
some authors as cold temperate and by others as warm
temperate. Stephenson (e.g. 1948) was the leading proponent
of the former view and in this he was followed by Hedgpeth
(1957) who, largely on the basis of a synthesis by Ekman
(1953), produced a map of the littoral zoogeographic prov-
inces of the world. In this map Hedgpeth placed a cold
temperate zone on the western side of southern Africa
directly abutting on to, and indeed overlapping with, the
tropical zone of western Africa. In all other regions of the
world he had indicated a warm temperate zone lying between
the cold temperate and tropical zones. Others who followed
this view were Knox (1960) and Michanek (1979). Ekman
(1953) regarded the region in question as warm temperate, as
did Briggs (1974), Bolton (1986), Hoek (e.g. 1984), and
Liining (1985). It should be noted that the question is seen
from different standpoints by different authors; thus Ekman,
Briggs, and Hedgpeth were concerned soley with animal
distributions, whereas Bolton, Hoek, and Liining dealt with
plants. Stephenson took both into account. Again, Stephenson
was concerned only with intertidal organisms and his bound-
aries are decidedly sharper than those produced by some
other authors, who included consideration of the deep sub-
littoral where distributions show fewer differences between
east and west. This is due to the fact, as pointed out by Brown
& Jarman (1978), that sea temperatures are much less vari-
able in deeper waters, ranging from only about 12-14C
throughout the year from Liideritz on the west coast to Port
Elizabeth in the east. The subject is well reviewed by Brown
& Jarman (1978) who adhered to the Stephenson viewpoint,
and by Bolton (1986) who takes the opposite line; it is also
mentioned by John & Lawson (1989) and Lawson (1988).
Bolton (1986) points out that Stephenson (1948) con-
sidered large stands of kelps to indicate cold temperate
conditions, as in the northern hemisphere. Had Stephenson
realized that Ecklonia maxima and Laminaria pallida under
162
LAWSON, SIMONS & ISAAC
Plate 7 Aeodes orbitosa growing over encrusting corallines on the pier at Swakopmund.
laboratory conditions actually grow best at higher tempera-
tures than most other kelps (17.5-20C for optimal gameto-
phyte growth for the former and 15C for the latter), he might
have concluded differently. Similarly, Macrocystis angusti-
folia has an optimum for gametophytic growth at 14.16C and
17.5C for reproduction (Branch, 1974). But it should per-
haps be borne in mind that temperatures which are optimal
for growth in the laboratory do not always necessarily reflect
what actually happens in nature. The figures given by Bolton
(1986), for instance, indicate that Ecklonia occurs on parts of
the west coast of South Africa where the mean temperature
for the warmest month does not rise much above 13, which is
well below the temperatures for optimum growth given
above. Further possible support for the warm temperate
view, however, is given by Lawson (1988), who has sug-
gested, on the basis of ordination, that the marine flora of
the western side of southern Africa has more in common
with those of Uruguayo-Bonaerense and Uruguay in South
America than with that of the more strictly cold temperate
one of Patagonia (see Kiihnemann, 1972). If this is indeed a
warm temperate marine climate continuous with that of the
south coast of South Africa how may the biotic discontinuity
that exists between the two be explained? A possible reason
to explain the somewhat anomalous situation where two
largely different warm temperate floras lie adjacent to one
another without completely mixing, may be that mean sea
temperatures along the south coast are generally appreciably
higher than those of the west coast and also show a wider
range between coldest and warmest months (see fig. 2 in
Bolton, 1986).
ALGAL FLORA OF NAMIBIA
163
Table 1 Distribution of the Namibian marine algal flora within and Table 1 cont.
to the north and south of Namibia. The species are arranged in a
geographical sequence.
Angola Namibia South Africa Species
North Centre South West South and
Species south-east
Angola Namibia South Africa
North Centre South West South and
south-east
Codium decorticatum + + +
Viva uncialis + + H
Enteromorpha linza + + H
E. compressa + +
Caulacanthus ustulatus + + + H
Centroceras clavulatum + + + H
Gracilaria verrucosa + + + H
Plocamium suhrii + +
Acrosorium maculatum + + -\
Bryopsis plumosa + + H
Hypnea musciformis + +
Viva fasciata + +
Grateloupia filicina + H
Colpomenia sinuosa + H
Enteromorpha tubulosa +
Gigartina teedii + +
Cladophora capensis + + H
C. contexta + + H
C. flagelliformis + + H
C. mirabilis + + H
Laminaria schinzii + + H
Aristothamnion collabens + + -
Ceramium atrorubescens + + -
Gymnogongrus complicatus + +
G. dilatatus + + -
G. vermicularis + +
Hildenbrandia rubra + +
Kallymenia schizophylla + +
Pachymenia camosa + +
Phyllymenia belangeri + +
Polysiphonia urbana + +
Suhria vittata + +
Nothogenia ovalis + +
Chaetomorpha robusta + +
Streblocladia camptocladia + +
S. fasciculifera +
Hypnea ceramioides +
Codium fragile + +
Ralfsia expansa + +
Ceramium arenarium + +
Chondria capensis + +
Gymnogongrus glomeratus + +
Iridaea capensis + +
Nothogenia erinacea + +
Plocamium rigidum + +
Porphyra capensis + +
Pterosiphonia cloiophylla + +
Aeodes orbitosa + +
Ceramium flaccidum +
Hypnea spicifera +
Platysiphonia miniata +
Acrosorium acrospermum + +
Ceramium diaphanum + +
Heringia mirabilis + +
Tayloriella tenebrosa + +
Bryopsis caespitosa +
Hincksia confervoides +
Plocamium corallorhiza +
P. vulgare +
Gelidium pristoides Unspecified
Codium duthieae + +
Enteromorpha prolifera +
Endarachne binghamiae +
Arthrocardia palmata +
Hypnea ? tenuis +
Viva nematoides +
Hincksia granulosa +
Acrosorium cincinnatum
Antithamnion leptocladum
Audouinella hypneae
Cryptonemia hibernica
Cryptopleura calophylloides
Epymenia capensis
Erythrotrichia welwitschii
Gelidium pusillum
Iridaea elongata
Lomentaria patens
Nothogenia magnifica
Ophidocladus simplidusculus
Rhodophyllis reptans
Schottera nicaeensis
Stylonema alsidii
Enteromorpha atroviridis
E. bulbosa
Chordariopsis capensis
Laminaria pallida
Carpoblepharis flacdda
Ceramium obsoletum
C. planum complex
Epymenia obtusa
Gigartina bracteata
G. radula
Polysiphonia virgata
Schizymenia obovata
Viva capensis
Papenfussiella gradlis
Callithamnion hookeri
Carpoblepharis minima
Gymnogongrus corymbosa
Haraldiophyllum bonnemaisonii
Rhodymenia linearis
Petalonia debilis
Chylocladia capensis
Plocamium cornutum
P. glomeratum
Streblocladia corymbifera
Chaetomorpha linum
Heterosiphonia dubia
Rhodymenia natalensis
Arthrocardia carinata
Derbesia lamourouxii
Actinococcus latior
Euhymenia schizophylla
Herposiphonia heringii
Bryopsis tenuis
Codium isaadi
Desmarestia firma
Ecklonia maxima
Scytosiphon lomentarius
Arthrocardia filicula
A. setchellii
Botryocarpa prolifera
Botryoglossum platycarpum
Champia lumbricalis
Delesseria papenfussii
Gelidium micropterum
Gigartina scutellata
Hymenena venosa
Pleonosporium harveyanum
Polyopes constrictus
Polysiphonia atrorubescens
Trematocarpus flabellatus
Leathesia difformis
Splachnidium rugosum
Gigartina stiriata
164
The list of species given below incorporates all known
records and contains 136 identified species whose known
distributions on southern African shores are displayed in
Table 1 , as well as at least 35 taxa assigned only to genera. It
is evident that most (97) Namibian seaweeds occur also on the
west coast of South Africa: even in the north of Namibia 44
species out of 57 identified plants are species that occur on the
west coast of South Africa with 21 endemics involved; the
other two segments, namely central (Swakopmund area) and
south (Liideritz area), contain respectively 89 and 83 identi-
fied species. An interesting point is that whereas about 74%
of all the taxa present in the south segment are common with
the west coast of South Africa, the comparative figure for the
central segment is only 62% in fact, Swakopmund is notable
for having 20 (22% of the total identified) species apparently
not occurring on the west coast of South Africa. By contrast
elements of the Angolan seaweed flora are remarkable for
their very poor representation 14 in all, with eight of these
of very wide distribution or even cosmopolitan.
The overall concept of the Namibian seaweed flora that
emerges is of an attenuating northward extension of the flora
of the west coast of South Africa that abruptly terminates
somewhere near the border with Angola. Less noticeable, but
nevertheless significant, is the change of species composition
at Swakopmund. Others have also observed biotic changes in
that vicinity, for instance, a reduction in frequency of the
Cape rock lobster, Jasus lalandii, north of 25S (Pollock &
Beyers, 1981). A possible explanation for these changes is
that the relative wind stress and concomitant water circula-
tion is reduced here and to the north (Agenbag & Shannon,
1988).
Table 1 shows discontinuities that seem somewhat anoma-
lous. Thus Grateloupia filicina, for example, is apparently
absent between the Kunene River mouth and Luderitz, and
Colpomenia sinuosa is recorded only in the Luderitz area of
Namibia while being present in Angola and the southern
Cape. Again Aeodes orbitosa, and some othe species such as
Ceramium flaccidum, have been found all the way from
northern Namibia to the southern coast of Africa except at
Swakopmund. Two possible reasons for these anomalies are
that there have been misidentifications and/or inadequate
collection since it is somewhat presumptuous to discuss
discontinuities of distribution on the rather meagre data
available. It is hoped, however, that this presentation will
serve as a useful check-list for further studies of the respective
floras.
ANNOTATED LIST OF SPECIES
The Western African seaweed checklists of Lawson & Price
(1969) and Price et al. (1978, 1986, 1988) cite unpublished
lists prepared by one of us (R.H.S.). These lists include the
specimens collected on the trip with which this paper is
concerned, together with identifications of algae collected by
Penrith & Kensley, and other miscellaneous records from
Namibia. We have included all these in the list that follows
and have added all earlier records of marine algae from this
coast as well as algae mentioned by Penrith & Kensley (1970 a
& b), Kensley & Penrith (1973, 1980) and the recent identifi-
cations by Wynne (1986). Where records of other authors are
cited an asterisk(*) indicates that we have been able to
LAWSON, SIMONS & ISAAC
confirm independently the presence of the species in question
at the given locality. Sites may be identified by the following
letters:
AB Agate Beach, AF Angra Fria, CF Cape Frio (and
False Cape Frio), D Diaz Point (Luderitz area), EB
Elizabeth Bay, FB Flesh Bay, G Grossebucht, HB
Halifax Bay, HL Honolulu (near Kunene River mouth),
K Kaokoveld, KR Kunene River, L Luderitz, MB
Mowe Bay, N Namibia (used when locality is not men-
tioned), RP Rocky Point, S Swakopmund, TB Torra
Bay, TC Terrace Bay, TS Toscanini, U Unjab, WB
Walvis Bay.
Specimens are deposited in BOL, the Herbarium of the
Department of Botany, University of Cape Town.
CHLOROPHYCEAE
Bryopsis caespitosa Suhr ex Kiitz. MB
Bryopsis plumosa (Huds.) Agardh EB, N (Lawson & Price,
1969), S.
Bryopsis tenuis Levr. L, ?N (Lawson & Price, 1969).
Bryopsis spp. EB, L, RP, S, TB, TC.
Chaetomorpha aerea (Dillwyn) Kiitz. see Chaetomorpha linum.
Chaetomorpha linum (O. F. Mull.) Kiitz. S (Wynne, 1986, as
C. aerea)*.
Chaetomorpha robusta (Aresch.) Papenf. MB, RP, S, TB,
TC.
Chaetomorpha spp. D, S, TB.
Cladophora capensis (Agardh) De Toni D, EB, HB, L
(Penrith & Kensley, 1970a)*, MB, RP (Penrith & Kensley,
1970ft)*, S, TB,TC.
Cladophora contexta Levr. EB, L, MB, S.
Cladophora flagelliformis (Suhr) Kiitz. EB, S (Wynne,
1986)*, TB,L.
Cladophora mirabilis (Agardh) Rabenh. CF (Kensley &
Penrith, 1980), KR (Kensley & Penrith, 1980), L, N (Lawson
& Price, 1969), RP, S (Wynne, 1986)*, TB, TC.
Cladophora virgata (Agardh) Kiitz. see Cladophora
flagelliformis.
Cladophora sp. EB.
Codium decorticatum (Woodw.) M. Howe MB, N (Lawson &
Price, 1969), RP, S (Silva, 1960; Wynne, 1986)*.
Codium duthieae P. C. Silva L, MB, ?N (Lawson & Price,
1969), RP (Penrith & Kensley, 1970&), S.
Codium fragile subsp. capense P. C. Silva D, EB, L (Penrith
& Kensley, 1970a, Silva, 1959), N (Lawson & Price, 1969;
Schmidt, 1923 as C.fragile), RP, S (Silva, 1959; Wynne,
1986)*, TB,U.
Codium isaacii P. C. Silva L (Silva, 1959), N (Lawson &
Price, 1969).
Codium sp. S.
Derbesia lamourouxii (J. Agardh) Solier L.
Enteromorpha atro-viridis (Levr.) Wynne G, L (Penrith &
Kensley, 1970a as Ulva atroviridis*) , S (Wynne, 1986).
Enteromorpha bulbosa (Suhr) Kiitz. EB, S.
Enteromorpha compressa (L.) Grev. S.
Enteromorpha linza (L.) J. Agardh L, S.
Enteromorpha prolif era (O. F. Mull.) J. Agardh MB, RP.
Enteromorpha tubulosa Kiitz. RP.
Enteromorpha spp. AF (Kensley & Penrith, 1980), CF
(Kensley & Penrith, 1980), HB, L, N (Lawson & Price,
1969), S.
Viva atroviridis Levr. see Enteromorpha atro-viridis.
ALGAL FLORA OF NAMIBIA
Viva capensis Aresch. MB, L, S (Wynne, 1986).
Ulvafasciata Delile S.
Ulva nematoidea Bory S (Wynne 1986)*.
Ulva uncialis (Kiitz.) De Toni L (Pilger, 1908 as U. uncialis
Suhr), MB, N (Dinter, 1928 as Ulva capensis; Lawson &
Price, 1969).
Ulva spp. EB, L, MB, N (Lawson & Price, 1969), RP, S, TB,
TC, U.
Urospora sp. S.
PHAEPHYCEAE
Chordaria flagelliformis (O. F. Mull.) Agardh N (Dinter,
1919) probably Chordariopsis capensis according to Price
et al. (1978).
Chordariopsis capensis (Agardh) Kylin CF (Kensley &
Penrith, 1980)*, EB, L (Penrith & Kensley, 1970a)*, N
(Price et al., 1978), RP, S (Wynne, 1986)*, TB.
Colpomenia sinuosa (Roth) Derb. & Sol. AB, D, EB, N
(Price etal., 1978).
Desmarestia firma (Agardh) Skottsb. L (Price et al., 1978).
See notes in Price et al. (1978) on this entity.
Ecklonia maxima (Osbeck) Papenf. EB, HB, L, N (Price et
al., 1978), S (Wynne, 1986 'in the drift'. Wynne also
mentions that his species occurs at RP and cites a letter
from Kensley on this, but we have not been able to find it
referred to in Penrith and Kensley [1970ft]).
Ectocarpus spp. N (Price et al., 1978), RP, S.
Endarachne binghamiae J. Agardh RP.
Hincksia granulosa (Smith) P. C. Silva S (Wynne, 1986 as
Giffordia granulosa).
Laminaria digitata forma ensifolia (Kiitz.) Foslie N (Dinter,
1922), WB (Foslie, 1893). See note in Price et al.
(1978).
Laminaria ochroleuca Bach. Pyl. N (Delf & Michell, 1921).
See note in Price et al. (1978).
Laminaria pallida Grev. EB, L, N (Delf & Michell, 1921;
Price et al., 1978; Schmidt & Gerloff, 1957). WB (Delf &
Michell, 1921). It should be noted that some doubt attaches
to the presence of L. pallida in the Liideritz area since
differences between L. pallida and L. schinzii are not clear
cut and juvenile and inshore plants of the latter often have
solid stipes.
Laminaria schinzii Foslie EB, L, MB, N (De Toni, 1895;
Dinter, 1922; Feldmann, 1946; John et al., 1981; Lawson et
al., 1975; Price et al., 1978; Pilger, 1908; Schmidt &
Gerloff, 1957), RP (Penrith & Kensley, 1907ft)*, S (Wynne,
1986)*, TC, WB (Barton, 1893; Foslie, 1893).
Laminaria sp. L (Penrith & Kensley, 1970a).
Leathesia difformis (L.) Aresch. D, EB, L, N (Price et al.,
1978).
Myriogloia sp. EB, N (Price et al., 1978), S.
Papenfussiella gracilis Kylin N (Price et al., 1978), S.
Petalonia debilis (O. F. Mull.) Kuntze EB, N (Price et al.,
1978), S.
Ralfsia expansa (J. Agardh) J. Agardh CF, EB, N (see note in
Price et al. [1978]), S.
Ralfsia sp. KR (Kensley & Penrith, 1980).
Scytosiphon lomentaria (Lyngbye) Link EB, L, N (Price et
al., 1978).
Splachnidium rugosum (L.) Grev. EB, G, HB, L (Penrith &
Kensley, 1970a)*, N (Price et al., 1978).
?Zonaria tempta HB, N (see note in Price et al. [1978]).
165
RHODOPHYCEAE
Acrosorium acrospermum (J. Agardh) Kylin RP, TB, TC,
TS, N (Price etal., 1986), S.
Acrosorium cincinnatum Wynne S (Wynne, 1986), N (Price et
al., 1986)*.
Acrosorium maculatum (Kiitz.) Papenf. L, S, N (Lawson et
al., 1975; Price etal., 1986).
Acrosorium sp. L, MB, S, TB, TC, N (Price et al., 1986).
Actinococcus latior Schmitz L (Pilger, 1908), N (Price et al.,
1978), WB (Dinter, 1917).
Aeodes orbitosa (Suhr) Schmitz AF (Kensley & Penrith,
1980), D, EB, CF, (Kensley & Penrith, 1980), G, HB, KR
(Kensley & Penrith, 1980), L (Penrith & Kensley, 1970a)*,
MB, (Penrith & Kensley, 1970ft), N (Price et al., 1986),
RP, U.
Aeodes sp. N (Price et al., 1986).
Antithamnion leptocladum (Mont.) Wynne S (Wynne, 1986),
N (Price etal., 1986).
Antithamnion sp. L, RP, N (Price et al., 1986).
Aristothamnion collabens (Rudolphi) Papenf. EB, G, HB, L,
N (Dinter, 1918 as A. purpuriferum; Price et al., 1986), S
(Wynne, 1986)*, TC.
Arthrocardia attenuata Manza see Arthrocardia palmata.
Arthrocardia carinata (Kiitz.) Johansen L (Pilger, 1908 as
Corallina carinata), N (Price et al., 1986), S.
Arthrocardia filicula (Lam.) Johansen in Seagrief L, N (Price
etal., 1986).
Arthrocardia palmata (Ellis & Sol.) Aresch. MB, N (Price et
al., 1986, as Arthrocardia attenuata).
Arthrocardia setchellii Manza L.
Arthrocardia sp. D, L (Penrith & Kensley, 1970a)*, RP
(Penrith & Kensley, 1970ft)*, TB, N (Price et al., 1986),
TC.
Audouinella hypneae (B0rgesen) G. W. Lawson & D. John S
(Wynne, 1986), N (Price et al., 1986).
Bostrychia moritziana (Sender ex Kiitz.) J. Agardh N (Post,
1963; Price etal., 1986).
Botryocarpa prolifera Grev. EB, L, N (Price et al., 1986).
Botryoglossum platycarpum (Turner) Kiitz. EB, L (Simons,
1974; Price etal., 1986).
Callithamnion hookeri (Dillwyn) Gray S (Wynne, 1986), N
(Price etal., 1986).
Carpoblepharis flaccida (Agardh) Kiitz. L (Pilger, 1908)*, N
(Price et al., 1986), S, WB (Delf & Michell, 1921).
Carpoblepharis minima Bart. N (Dinter, 1918; Price et al.,
1986), S (Wynne, 1986).
Carpoblepharis sp. N (Price et al., 1986), S.
Carradoria virgata (Agardh) Kylin see Polysiphonia virgata.
Caulacanthus ustulatus (Mert.) Kiitz. EB, L, MB, N (Price et
al., 1986; Searles, 1968), RP, S (Wynne, 1986)*, TB.
Caulacanthus sp. N (Price et al., 1986), TB.
Centroceras clavulatum (Agardh) Mont. D, EB, L (Pilger,
1908)*, MB, N (Price et al., 1986; Searles, 1968), RP, S
(Wynne, 1986)*, TB,TC.
Ceramium arenarium Simons L (Simons, 1966), N (Price et
al., 1986; Simons, 1966), S (Wynne, 1986), TB.
Ceramium atrorubescens Kylin L (Simons, 1966), S Simons,
1966, Wynne, 1986), TB, N (Price et al., 1986), U, WB
(Simons, 1966).
Ceramium capense Kiitz. see Ceramium obsoletum.
Ceramium diaphanum (Lightf.) Roth TB (Dinter, 1919; Price
et al., 1986), WB (Delf & Michell, 1921).
Ceramium flaccidum (Kiitz.) Ardiss. G (Simons, 1966, as
166
Ceramium papenfussianum) HB, HL, KR, L, N (Price et
al., 1986, as Ceramium papenfussianum) .
Ceramium obsoletum^ Agardh EB (Simons, 1966), L (Simons,
1966), N (Dinter, 1917; Price et al., 1986 as C.capense),
WB (Delf & Michell, 1921 as C.obsolatum) (= Microdadia
capense Papenf.
Ceramium papenfussianum Simons See Ceramium flaccidum.
Ceramium planum complex sensu Simons 1968 L, N (Price et
al., 1986), S (Wynne, 1986).
Ceramium spp. S (Wynne, 1986), TC, TS, N (Price et al.,
1986).
Chaetangium erinaceum (Turner) Papenf. see Nothogenia
erinacea.
Chaetangium magnificum Pilger see Nothogenia magnifica.
Chaetangium ornatum (L.) Kiitz. see Nothogenia erinacea.
Chaetangium ovale (Suhr) Papenf. see Nothogenia ovalis.
Champia lumbricalis (L.) Desv. AB, D, EB, G, L (Penrith &
Kensley, 1970a; Simons, 1974), N (Price et al., 1986).
Chondria capensis (Harvey) Falkenb. CF, L, MB, N (Delf &
Michell, 1921; Lawson et al., 1975; Price et al., 1986;
Round, 1981; Schmidt & Gerloff, 1967; Simons, 1974), RP,
S (Wynne, 1986)*, WB (Dinter, 1919) TB, TC.
Chondria sp. CF (Kensley & Penrith, 1980), KR (Kensley &
Penrith, 1980), N (Price et al., 1986).
Chylocladia capensis Harvey L, N (Price et al., 1986), S.
Chylocladia sp. KR, N (Price et al., 1986), RP, TC.
Corallina carinata Kiitz. see Arthrocardia carinata.
Corallina sp. (Corniculariae) MB.
Corallina spp. S (Wynne, 1986), RP, N (Price et al., 1986), S,
TB, TS.
Cryptonemia hibernica Guiry & L. Irvine N (Price et al.,
1986), S (Wynne, 1986).
Cryptopleura calophylloides (J. Agardh) Wynne N (Price et
al., 1986), S (Wynne, 1986).
Delesseria papenfussii Wynne EB, N (Price et al., 1986).
Epymenia capensis (J. Agardh) Papenf. N (Dinter, 1926;
Schmidt & Gerloff, 1957, as Rhodymenia capensis Price et
al., 1986), WB (Delf & Michell, 1921, as Epymenia steno-
loba).
Epymenia obtusa (Grev.) Kutz. EB, L (Pilger, 1908)*, N
(Delf & Michell, 1921, Price et al., 1986, Simons, 1974), S
(Wynne, 1986)*, TC.
Erythrotrichia welwitschii (Rupr.) Batters S.
Euhymenia schizophylla Kiitz. L (Pilger, 1908), N (Price et
al., 1986).
Gelidium micropterum Kiitz. EB, L, N (Price et al., 1986).
Gelidium pristoides (Turner) Kiitz. N (Price et al., 1986).
Gelidium pusillum (Stackh.) Le Jolis N (Price et al., 1986), S.
Gelidium spp. MB, N (Price et al., 1986), RP.
Gigartina bracteata (Gmelin) Setch. & N. Gardner HB, S
(Wynne, 1986).
Gigartina radula (Esper) J. Agardh AB, D, EB, HB, L
(Penrith & Kensley, 1970a)*, S, TC.
Gigartina scabiosa (Kiitz.) Papenf. see G.scutellata.
Gigartina scutellata (Hering) Simons EB, L, N (Price et al.,
1988).
Gigartina stiriata (Turner) J. Agardh D, EB, G, L (Penrith &
Kensley, 1970a)*, N (Price et al., 1988).
Gigartina teedii (Roth) Lamouroux N (Dinter, 1921; Price et
al., 1988), RP, S (Wynne, 1986).
t The plant to which the name Ceramium obsoletum Agardh has been applied
is apparently unnamed since the Ceramium capense cited by Simons (1966: 164)
is not congeneric with Ceramium.
LAWSON, SIMONS & ISAAC
Gigartina spp. N (Price et al., 1988), RP (Penrith & Kensley,
19706)*.
Gracilaria verrucosa (Huds.) Papenf. L (Rotmann, 1987), N
(Isaac, 1956; Michanek, 1971, 1975; Price et al., 1988) S
(Wynne, 1986)*, TC, WB.
Grateloupiafilicina (Wulf.) J. Agardh EB, HB, L, N (Price et
al., 1988).
Griffithsia confervoides Suhr (including G. cymosa Simons)
MB, N (Price et al., 1988), TB, TC, TS.
Gymnogongrus complicatus (Kiitz.) Papenf. L, MB, N
(Price et al., 1988), S (Wynne, 1986)*, TB, TC, TS.
Gymnogongrus corymbosus J. Agardh N (Price et al., 1988),
5 (Wynne 1986).
Gymnogongrus dilatatus (Turner) J. Agardh L (Pilger,
1909)*, N (Price et al., 1988), S (Wynne, 1986)*, TC.
Gymnogongrus glomeratus J. Agardh AB, AF (Kensley &
Penrith, 1980), EB, D, L (Penrith & Kensley, 1970a)*, N
(Kensley & Penrith, 1980; Price et al., 1988), RP (Penrith
6 Kensley, 19706), S (Wynne, 1986)*, TC, TS.
Gymnogongrus vermicularis (Agardh) J. Agardh CF, HB,
KR, L, MB, N (Price et al.,1988), S, TC, TS.
Gymnogongrus spp. G, KR, MB, N (Price et al., 1988), S.
Haraldiophyllum bonnemaisonii (Grev.) Zinova prox. S
(Wynne, 1986).
Heringia mirabilis (Agardh) J. Agardh S (Wynne, 1986), TC.
Heringia sp. MB.
Herposiphonia heringii (Harvey) Falkenb. L.
Heterosiphonia dubia (Suhr) Falkenb. S (Wynne, 1986).
Heterosiphonia sp. TB.
Hildenbrandia rubra (Sommerfelt) Menegh. EB, L, RP, S,
TB.
Hymenena venosa (L.) Kylin EB, L.
Hypnea ceramioides Kiitz. RP (Penrith & Kensley, 19706).
Hypnea eckloni Suhr see Hypnea musciformis note in Delf &
Michell (1921).
Hypnea musciformis (Wulf.) Lamouroux S (Wynne, 1986),
WB (Delf & Michell, 1921, as Hypnea eckloni).
Hypnea spicifera (Suhr) Harvey AB, KR (Kensley & Penrith,
1980), L, RP (Penrith & Kensley, 19706)*.
Hypnea (?)tenuis Kylin KR.
Hypnea spp. KR, L, MB, RP, S, TC.
Hypoglossum sp. TC.
Iridaea capensis J. Agardh CF, D, EB, G, HL, L (Penrith
& Kensley, 1970a)*; MB, S (Wynne, 1986, as Iridaea
capensis)* , TC.
Iridaea elongata Suhr WB (Delf & Michell, 1921).
Kallymenia schizophylla J. Agardh L, S (Wynne, 1986)*, TC.
? 'Kallymenia sp. L.
Lithophyllum sp. RP.
Lithothamnion sp. D, L (Penrith & Kensley, 1970a), RP
(Penrith & Kensley, 19706).
Lomentaria patens Kiitz. WB (Delf & Michell, 1921).
Microdadia sp. TC.
Neuroglossum binderianum Kiitz. EB, L.
Nitophyllum fissum (Grev.) J. Agardh L (Pilger, 1908). See
Hymenena venosa.
Nothogenia erinacea (Turner) Parkinson CF, L, MB, RP
(Penrith & Kensley, 19706 as Chaetangium erinaceum), L
(Pilger, 1908 as Chaetangium ornatum), S (Wynne, 1986)*,
TB, WB (Delf & Michell, 1921, as Chaetangium ornatum).
Nothogenia magnifica (Pilger) J. Price S (Pilger, 1908; Price et
al.,1986).
Nothogenia ovalis (Suhr) Parkinson G, L (Penrith & Kensley,
1970a as Chaetangium ovale)* , MB.
ALGAL FLORA OF NAMIBIA
Ophidodadus simpliciusculus (P. Crouan & H. Crouan ex J.
Agardh) Falkenb. S (Wynne, 1986).
Orcasia pulla Simons see Streblodadia camptodada.
Pachymenia carnosa (J. Agardh) J. Agardh AF (Kensley &
Penrith, 1980), CF (Kensley & Penrith, 1980)*, EB, KR
(Kensley & Penrith, 1980), L, MB, S (Wynne, 1986)*, TC.
Phyllymenia belangeri (Bory) Setch.& N.Gardner CF, L, S
(Wynne, 1986)*, TB, TC.
Platysiphonia miniata (J. Agardh) B0rgesen EB, L, MB, RP,
TB.
Platysiphonia sp. MB.
Pleonosporium harveyanum (J. Agardh) De Toni L.
Plocamium corallorhiza (Turner) Harvey K.
Plocamium cornutum (Turner) Harvey D, EB, L (Pilger,
1 908) *,S( Wynne, 1986)*.
Plocamium glomeratum J. Agardh S (Wynne, 1986)*.
Plocamium rigidum Bory L, RP, S (Wynne, 1986)*, TB, TC,
MB.
Plocamium suhrii Kiitz. RP, TC.
Plocamium vulgare Lamouroux CF, TC, MB.
Poly opes constrictus (Turner) J. Agardh L.
Polysiphonia atrorubescens (Dillwyn) Grev. L.
Polysiphonia urbana Harvey CF, EB, HL, RP, TC, U, WB
(Delf & Michell, 1921 as Polysiphonia corymbiferd).
Polysiphonia virgata (Agardh) Sprengel EB, G, S (Wynne,
1986)*.
Polysiphonia sp. S (Wynne, 1986). Polysiphonia spp. L, S, U.
Porphyra capensis Kutz. AF (Kensley & Penrith, 1980), CF
(Kensley & Penrith, 1980), D, EB, G, HL, L (Penrith &
Kensley, 1970a)*, N (Dinter, 1926; John et al., 1979;
Piccone, 1884; Pilger, 1908; Schmidt & Gerloff, 1957), RP,
S (Wynne, 1986), TC, U. See remarks on p. 159.
Porphyra sp. S.
Pterosiphonia doiophylla (Agardh) Falkenb. AB, L, RP, S
(Wynne, 1986)*, TC.
Rhodophyllis reptans (Suhr) Papenf. S (Wynne, 1986).
Rhodymenia linearis J. Agardh S (Wynne, 1986).
Rhodymenia natalensis Kylin S (Wynne, 1986).
Rhodymenia sp. CF (Kensley & Penrith, 1980), KR.
Schizymenia obovata (J. Agardh) J. Agardh L, S (Wynne,
1986)*.
Schottera nicaeensis (Lamouroux ex Duby) Guiry & Hollen-
berg S (Wynne, 1986).
Streblodadia camptodada (Mont.) Falkenb. AF (Kensley &
Penrith, 1980 as Orcasia pulla), CF (Kensley & Penrith,
1980 as Orcasia pulla), KR (Kensley & Penrith, 1980 as
Orcasia pulla), MB, RP, S (Wynne, 1986), TC, TS, U.
Streblodadia corymbifera (Agardh) Kylin RP, S (Wynne,
1986).
Streblodadia fasciculi/era (Kutz.) Falkenb. RP, TC.
Stylonema alsidii (Zanard.) Drew S (Wynne, 1986).
Suhria vittata (L.) J. Agardh EB, L (Pilger, 1908)*, MB, S
(Wynne, 1986)*.
Tayloriella tenebrosa (Harvey) Kylin MB, RP, S, TB, TS.
Tayloriella virgata (Agardh) Papenf. see Polysiphonia virgata.
Tayloriella sp. RP, TC.
Trematocarpus flabellatus (J. Agardh) De Toni EB, L, N
(Price et al., 1986).
CYANOPHYCEAE
Lyngbya sp. L (Penrith & Kensley, 1970a).
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS. The authors are grateful to the State Depart-
ment of Agriculture of the Union of South Africa (now the Republic
167
of South Africa) for providing a four-wheel-drive vehicle and all its
fuel and maintenance needs. They also thank the Administration of
Consolidated Diamond Mines for permission to visit Elizabeth Bay.
The University of Cape Town and the Council for Scientific and
Industrial Research helped by funding some of the travelling ex-
penses of the party.
We are indebted to Miss Judith Graves for her participation in the
original field excursion of 1957, and to Dr D. M. John and Mr J. H.
Price of The Natural History Museum, London, who read the paper
critically and provided additional information and advice, and to the
Photographic Unit of the museum for providing black and white
prints from the colour slides made by one of us (G.W.L.).
REFERENCES
Anon. 1963. Africa pilot 2. London.
Anon. 1964. Handbuch der Westkiiste Afrikas II. Teil von Calabar River bis
Cape Hangklip. Hamburg.
Barton, E. S. 1893. A provisional list of the marine algae of the Cape of Good
Hope. /. Bot., Land. 31. 53-56, 81-84, 110-114, 138-144, 171-177, 202-210.
1896. Cape algae. /. Bot. Land. 34: 193-198.
Bolton, J. J. 1986. Marine phytogeography of the Benguela upwelling region
on the west coast of southern Africa: a temperature dependent approach.
Botanica mar. 29: 251-256.
& Anderson, R. J. 1988. Gradient analysis of seaweed communities
around the southern tip of Africa. Third Internal. Phycol. Congr., Monash
Univ., 79S8Abstr.:5.
Branch, M. 1974. Limiting factors for the gametes of three South African
laminariales. Investl. Rep. Sea Fish. Brch. S. Afr. 104: 1-38.
Briggs, J. C., 1974. Marine zoogeography. New York.
Bright, K. M. F. 1938. The South African intertidal zone and its relation to
ocean currents. III. An area on the northern part of the west coast. Trans.
R. Soc. S. Afr. 26: 67-88.
Brown, A. C. & Jarman, N.. 1978. Coastal marine habitats. In M.J.A. Werger
(Ed.), Biogeography and ecology of southern Africa 2: 1239-1277. [Mono-
graphiae Biologicae 31]. The Hague.
Delf, E. M. & Michell, M. R. 1921. The Tyson collection of marine algae. Ann.
Bolus Herb. 3: 89-119.
De Toni, G. B. 1895. Sylloge algarum omnium hucusque cognitarum III.
Sylloge Fucoidearum. Padova.
Dinter, K. 1919-1928. Index, der aus Deutsch-Sudwestafrika bis zum Jahre,
1917 bekannt gewordenen Pflanzenarten. Reprium Spec. nov. Regni veg. 16:
239-244; 17: 303-311; 18: 13-16, 248-256, 423-444; 19: 315-320; 22:
108-112, 375-383; 23: 130-137, 363-371; 24: 302-304.
Ekman, S. 1953. Zoogeography of the sea. London.
Feldmann, J. 1946. La flore marine des lies Atlantides. Mem. Soc. Biogeogr. 8:
395-435.
Koslie, M. 1893. Ueber eine neue Laminaria (Laminaria schinzii) aus Westafrika.
Bull. Herb. Boissier 1: 91-94.
Hedgpeth, J. W. 1957. Marine biogeography. Geol. Soc. Am. Memoir. 67:
359-382.
Hoek, C van den 1984. World- wide latitudinal and longitudinal distribution
patterns and their possible causes as illustrated by the distribution of
Rhodophycean genera. Helgolander wiss. Meeresunters. 38: 227-257.
Hommersand, M. H., 1986. The biogeography of the South African marine red
algae: a model. Botanica mar. 29: 257-270.
Isaac, W. E. 1937a. South African coastal waters in relation to coastal currents.
Geographical Rev. 27: 651-664.
19376. Studies of South African seaweed vegetation. 1 . West coast from
Lamberts Bay to the Cape of Good Hope. Trans. R. Soc. S. Afr. 25:
115-151.
1949. Studies of South African seaweed vegetation. II. South coast:
Rooi Els to Gansbaai, with special reference to Gansbaai. Trans. R. Soc. S.
Afr. 32: 125-160.
1956. The ecology of Gracilaria confervoides (L.) Grev. in South Africa
with special reference to its ecology in the Saldanha-Langebaan lagoon.
Proc.lnt. Seaweed Symp. (Trondheim, 1955) 2: 173-185. London.
1957. The distribution, ecology and taxonomy of Porphyra on South
African coasts. Proc. Linn. Soc. Land. 168: 61-65.
& Hewitt, F. 1953. The morphology, geographical distribution and
ecology of Hypnea spicifera (Suhr) Harv. // S. Afr. Bot. 19: 73-84.
John, D. M. 1986. Littoral and sublittoral vegetation. In G. W. Lawson (Ed.)
Plant ecology in West Africa: systems and processes: 215-246. Chichester.
& Lawson, G. W. 1990. Littoral ecosystems of tropical West Africa. In A.
C. Mathieson & P. H. Nienhuis (Eds), Intertidal and littoral ecosystems.
Elsevier Series Ecosystems of the World 24 (in press).
168
LAWSON, SIMONS & ISAAC
& Price, J. H. 1981. Preliminary results from a recent survey of the
marine algal flora of Angola (southwestern Africa). Proc. Int. Seaweed
Symp. (Bangor, 1974) 8: 367-371. Menai Bridge.
Price, J. H., Maggs, C. A. & Lawson, G. W. 1979. Seaweeds of the
western coast of tropical Africa and adjacent islands: a critical assessment.
III. Rhodophyta (Bangiophyceae).Bw//. Br. Mus. not. Hist. (Bot.) 7: 69-82.
Kensley, B. & Penrith, M.-L. 1973. The constitution of the intertidal fauna of
rocky shores of Moc.amedes, southern Angola. Cimbebasia A, 2: 113-123.
1980. The constitution of the fauna of rocky intertidal shores of
South West Africa. Part III. The north coast from False Cape Frio to the
Kunene River. Cimbebasia A, 5: 201-214.
Knox, G. A. 1960. Littoral ecology and biogeography of the southern oceans.
Proc. R. Soc. B. 152: 577-624.
Kiihnemann, O., 1972. Bosquejo fitogeografico de la vegetation marina del
litoral argentine. Physis 31: 117-142.
Lawson, G. W. 1978. The distribution of seaweed floras in the tropical and
subtropical Atlantic Ocean: a quantitative approach. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 76:
177-193.
- 1988. Seaweed distribution patterns as revealed by ordination with
reference to the Atlantic and southern oceans. Helgolander wiss.
Meeresunters. 42: 187-197.
John, D. M. & Price, J. H. 1975. The marine algal flora of Angola: its
distribution and affinities. Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 70: 307-324.
& Price, J. H. 1969. Seaweeds of the western coast of tropical Africa and
adjacent islands: a critical assessment. I. Chlorophyta and Xanthophyta.
Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 62: 279-346.
Lewis, J. R. 1961. The littoral zone on rocky shores a biological or physical
entity? Oikos 12: 280-301.
Liming, K. 1985. Meeresbotanik. Stuttgart.
McLachlan, A. 1985. The ecology of two sandy beaches near Walvis Bay.
Madoqua 14: 155-163.
Michanek, G. 1971. A preliminary appraisal of world seaweed resources. Fish
Circ. 128. Roma.
1975. Seaweed resources of the ocean. Fish. Tech. Pap. 138. Roma.
1979. Phytogeographical provinces and seaweed distribution. Botanica
mar. 22: 375-391 .
Papenfuss, G. F. 1968. Notes on South African marine algae V. Jl S. Afr. Bot.
34: 267-287.
Penrith, M.-L. & Kensley, B. F. 1970a. The constitution of the intertidal fauna
of rocky shores of South West Africa. Part 1. Liideritzbucht. Cimbebasia A,
1: 191-239.
19706. The constitution of the fauna of rocky intertidal shores of
South West Africa. Part II Rocky Point. Cimbebasia A, 1: 243-268.
Piccone, A. 1884. Crociera del Corsaro alle isole Modern e Canarie del Capitano
Enrico d'Albertis. Alghe. Genova.
Pilger, R. 1908. Kleinere Beitrage zur Kenntnis der Meeresalgen 1. Hedwigia
48: 178-183.
Pollock, D. E. & Beyers, C. J. de B. 1981. Environment, distribution and
growth rates of west coast rock-lobster Jasus lalandii (H. Milne Edwards).
Trans. R. Soc. S. Afr. 44: 379-400.
Post, E. 1963. Zur Verbreitung und Okologie der Bostrychia-Caloglossa
Assoziation. Int. Rev. ges. Hydrobiol. 48: 47-152.
Price, J. H., John. D. M. & Lawson, G. W. 1978. Seaweeds of the western
coast of tropical Africa and adjacent islands: a critical assessment. II.
Phaeophyta. Bull. Br. Mus. not. Hist. (Bot.) 6: 87-182.
1986. Seaweeds of the western coast of tropical Africa and
adjacent islands: a critical assessment. IV. Rhodophyta (Florideae) 1.
Genera A-F. Bull. Br. Mus. not. Hist. (Bot.) 15: 1-122.
1988. Seaweeds of the western coast of tropical Africa and
adjacent islands: a critical assessment. IV. Rhodophyta (Florideae) 2.
Genera G. Bull. Br. Mus. nat. Hist. (Bot.) 18: 195-273.
Rotmann, K. W. G., 1987. The collection, utilization and potential farming of
red seaweeds in Namibia. Hydrobiologia 151/152: 301-305.
Round, F. E. 1981. The ecology of algae. Cambridge.
Searles, R. B. 1968. Morphological studies of red algae of the order Gigartinales.
Univ. Calif. Pubs. Bot. 43.
Schmidt, O. C. 1923. Beitrage zur Kenntnis der Gattung Codium Stackh.
Bibliotheca Bot. 91: 1-67.
& Gerloff, J. 1957. Die marine vegetation Afrikas in ihren Grundziigen
darstellt. Willdenowia 1: 709-756.
Seagrief, S. C. 1984. A catalogue of South African green, brown and red algae.
Mem. Bot. Surv. S. Afr. 47.
& Troughton, S. C. 1973. A guide to the literature on South African
marine algae. // S. Afr. Bot. 39: 95-109.
Shannon, L. V., Agenbag, J. J. & Buys, M. E. L. 1987. Large and mesoscale
features of the Angola Benguela front. In A. I. L. Payne, J. A. Gulland &
K. H. Brink (Eds) The Benguela and Comparable Ecosystems. S. Afr. J.
mar. Sci. 5: 11-34.
Nelson, G. & Jury, M. R. 1981. Hydrological and meteorological aspects
of upwelling in the south Benguela Current. In F. A. Richards (Ed.) Coastal
and estuarine sciences 1: 146-159.
Silva, P. C. 1959. The genus Codium (Chlorophyta) in South Africa. Jl S. Afr.
Bot. 25: 103-165.
1960. Codium (Chlorophyta) in the tropical western Atlantic. Nova
Hedwigia 1: 497-536.
Simons, R. H. 1964. Species of Plocamium on the South African coast. Bothalia
9: 153-168.
1966. The genus Ceramium in South Africa. Bothalia 9: 153-168.
1968. Notes on Ceramium planum Kiitzing, a red seaweed from South
Africa. // S. Afr. Bot. 34: 127-133.
1970. Marine algae from South Africa 1. Six new species from the inter-
and infra-tidal zones. Investl. Rep. Div. Sea Fish. Rep. S. Afr. 88: 1-13.
1974. Algae (including diatoms and seaweeds) In J. H. Day, N. A. H.
Millard & M. L. Penrith (Eds), A guide to the marine life on South African
shores. 2nd ed.: 239-261. Cape Town.
1983. The genus Trematocarpus (Sarcodiaceae, Rhodophyta) in southern
Africa and the exclusion of Sphaerococcus (Chondrus) scutellatus. Bothalia
14: 803-808.
& Hewitt, F. E. 1977. Marine algae from southern Africa 2. Morphology
and taxonomy of five foliaceous Floridiophyceae (Rhodophyta). Investl.
Rep. Div. Sea Fish. S. Afr. 110: 1-16.
Stephenson, T. A. 1939. The constitution of the intertidal fauna and flora of
South Africa. Part 1. J. Linn. Soc. (Zool.) 40: 478-536.
1944. The constitution of the intertidal fauna and flora of South Africa.
Part II. Ann. Natal Mus. 10: 261-358.
1948. The constitutiobn of the intertidal fauna and flora of South Africa.
Part III. Ann. Natal Mus. 11: 207-324.
& Stephenson, A. 1972. Life between tidemarks on rocky shores. San
Francisco.
& Day, J. H. 1940. The South African intertidal zone and its relation
to ocean currents. VIII Lambert's Bay and the west coast. Ann. Natal Mus.
9: 345-377.
Sverdrup, H. U., Johnson, M. W. & Hemming, R. H. 1942. The oceans. New
York.
Wynne, M. J. 1986. Report on a collection of benthic marine algae from the
Namibian coast (southwestern Africa). Nova Hedwigia 43: 311-355.
Bull. Br. Mus. nat. Hist.(Eot.) 20(2) 169-192 Issued 20 December 1990
The infrageneric classification of Gentiana
(Gentianaceae)
TING-NUNG HO ^nd SHANG-WU LIU
Northwest Plateau Institute of Biology, Academia Sinica, Xining, Qinghai, China
CONTENTS
Generic circumscription and status 170
Key to the genera in subtribe Gentianinae 170
Infrageneric classification 171
Taxonomic characters 172
Systematic treatment 178
Gentiana L 178
Key to the sections 178
Keys to the series 179
Classification 179
I. Sect. Otophora Kusn 179
1 . Ser. Otophorae Marquand 180
2. Ser. Decoratae Marquand 180
II. Sect. Cruciata Gaudin 180
III. Sect. Monopodiae (H. Smith) T.N.Ho 180
1. Ser. Monanthae (H. Smith) T.N.Ho 180
2. Ser. Verticillatae (Marquand) T.N.Ho 180
3. Ser. Ornatae (Marquand) T.N.Ho 180
4. Ser. Apteroideae (H. Smith) T.N.Ho 180
IV. Sect. Frigida Kusn 181
V. Sect. Gentiana 181
VI. Sect. Pneumonanthe (Gled.) Gaudin 181
VII. Sect. Phyllocalyx T.N.Ho 181
VIII. Sect. Calathianae Froelich 181
IX. Sect. Ciminalis (Adans.) Dumort 181
X. Sect. Isomeria Kusn 181
1 . Ser. Sikkimenses (Marquand) T.N.Ho 182
2. Ser. Depressae (H. Smith) T.N.Ho 182
3. Ser. Stragulatae T.N.Ho 182
4. Ser. Uniflorae (Marquand) T.N.Ho 182
XI. Sect. Microsperma T.N.Ho 182
1 . Ser. Suborbisepalae (Marquand) T.N.Ho 182
2. Ser. Tetramerae (Marquand) T.N.Ho 182
3. Ser. Annuae (Marquand) T.N.Ho 182
XII. Sect. Stenogyne Franchet 182
XIII. Sect. Dolichocarpa T.N.Ho 18 2
XIV. Sect. Chondrophyllae Bunge 182
1 . Ser. Fimbriatae Marquand 183
2. Ser. Rubicundae Marquand 18
3. Ser. Linearifoliae Marquand 183
4. Ser. Orbiculatae Marquand 18
5. Ser. Humiles Marquand 18
6. Ser. Capitatae T.N.Ho 18
7. Ser. Fastigiatae T.N.Ho 18
8. Ser. Napuliferae T.N.Ho 18
9. Ser. Conacre T.N.Ho I 83
10. Ser. Piasezkianae T.N.Ho 18
11. Ser. Grandiflorae Grossh. exT.N.Ho l g
XV. Sect. Fimbricorona T.N.Ho t8
Geographical distribution
Study materials
References . . 191
170
T.-N. HO&S.-W. LIU
SYNOPSIS. An infrageneric classification of the genus Gentiana L. is presented. The genus is divided into 15 sections,
of which five are subdivided into series, including 361 species. Two series, Coriaceae T.N. Ho and Grandiflorae
Grossh. ex T.N. Ho, are described as new, and the new combination, ser. Monanthae (H. Smith) T.N. Ho, is made.
Fimbricorona T.N. Ho is proposed as a new name for sect. Eurythalia (Borkh.) Griseb. Keys are given to the genera
in subtribe Gentianinae and the sections and series of Gentiana. The history of the infrageneric classification of
Gentiana, the characters used in infrageneric classification, and the geographical distribution of the genus are
discussed.
GENERIC CIRCUMSCRIPTION AND STATUS
The name Gentiana in its modern sense is generally accredited
to Tournefort (1700). His name was taken up by Linnaeus in
Genera plantarum (1737) and Species plantarum (1753).
Gentiana sensu lato, as traditionally circumscribed, is a
very heterogeneous assemblage of morphologically diverse
groups, including Tripterospermum, Crawfurdia, Megacodon,
and Gentianella sensu lato. Gentianella sensu lato further
consists of Gentianella sensu stricto, Comastoma, Gentianopsis,
and Pterygocalyx. Gentiana is circumscribed in the present
paper in the strict sense, as equivalent to subgenus Eugentiana
Kusn. This interpretation has been accepted widely by most
20th century authors on Gentianaceae, e.g. Smith (1936,
1965), Tutin (1972), Czerepanov (1973), Pringle (1977, 1978,
1979). It is narrower than Gentiana sensu lato mentioned
above, but much broader than Gentiana as defined by Holub
(1973) and Love & Love (1975) who restricted Gentiana to
the five European species treated by Tutin (1972) as sect.
Gentiana.
According to Gilg's comprehensive survey of the family
(1895), Gentiana is included in subfamily Gentianoideae,
tribe Gentianeae, subtribe Gentianinae. In subtribe
Gentianinae, it is more closely related to Crawfurdia,
Tripterospermum, and Megacodon than to Gentianella,
Comastoma, Gentianopsis, Lomatogonium, Lomatogoniopsis,
Swertia, and Halenia. It seems that these genera can be split
into two evolutionary groups the Gentiana group and the
Gentianella group. The two groups can be clearly distinguished
on the basis of the position of the floral glands: the Gentiana
group (Gentiana, Crawfurdia, Tripterospermum, and
Megacodon) has glands at the base of the ovary, while the
Gentianella group (Gentianella, Comastoma, Gentianopsis,
Lomatogonium, Lomatogoniopsis, Swertia, and Halenia} has
glands in foveae or spurs borne on the surface of the corolla
(epipetalous glands). In addition, the corolla bears plicae or
folds between the lobes in the Gentiana group (except in
Gentiana lutea L. and Megacodon), each lobe has 3 primary
vascular bundles, the calyx has a continuous intracalycular
membrane (except in Gentiana sect. Chondrophyllae and
sect. Calathianae which have obsolete membranes), and
calcium oxalate crystals have been reported in the leaf
mesophyll (except in sect. Calathianae}. In the Gentianella
group, there are no plicae or folds between the corolla-lobes
and there is no continuous intracalycular membrane, the
corolla-lobes have 5-9 vascular bundles, and calcium oxalate
crystals have not been found in the leaf mesophyll.
Crawfurdia and Tripterospermum are further characterized
by their climbing habit and by the calyx having 10 vascular
bundles in the former and 5 in the latter, and differ distinctly
from Gentiana in these characters.
Chromosome data have contributed little towards resolving
the problem of generic delimitation in the Gentianinae. From
previously reported chromosome data, we know that the
majority of perennial species of Gentiana are x = 6 or 13, 2n
= 12 or 26, less often x = 5, 7, 9, or 11, 2n = 10, 14, 18, 20,
22, 24, 30, 36, 40, 44, 48 or 52. The majority of annuals are x
= 5, 2n = 10, less often x = 13 or 19, 2n = 26 or 38. However,
in Gentianella, the chromosome number x = 9, 2n = 36 is
the commonest and most widespread one. The base number
is x = 9 or 13 in Swertia. Halenia has a base number of 11 , 2n
= 22. The diploid Comastoma has a base number of 5 in
common with Lomatogonium. Gentianopsis has two series, x
11 or 13, 2n = 44 or 78. However, in these genera,
sometimes more than one series of numbers may exist in the
same genus, even in the same section or within a group with
very similar morphological features. For example, Gentiana
frigida Haenke and G. froelichii Jan ex Reichenb., both
endemic to Europe and belonging to sect. Frigida, have
different chromosome base numbers, x 6 and x 7
respectively. Only about half the genera of Gentianaceae
have been investigated cytologically, and only selected
species rather than whole genera. Further study is clearly
necessary.
Most pollen grains in Gentianinae are 3-colporate,
less frequently 3-colpate (-colporoidate), or occasionally 4-
colporate (-colporoidate). The size of the pollen grains
(length of polar axis) ranges from 15 um to 65 urn. The shape
varies from peroblate to perprolate. The sexine patterns can
be classified into striate, striato-reticulate, reticulate, spin-
uliferous and smooth, and the diversity seems to follow the
generic or sectional classification. Most species of Gentiana
have striate sexine, rarely striato-reticulate (sect. Chondro-
phyllae and sect. Calathianae). The ora usually have
lateral extensions. Gentianopsis has typically reticulate,
heterobrochate pollen grains. The ora are distinctly delimited
or are visible only in lateral view. Swertia has heterogeneous
sexine features, i.e. striate, striato-reticulate, reticulate,
spinuliferous or smooth. Halenia has pollen grains which
are finely reticulate. Lomatogonium is characterized by the
presence of 'islands', and by the sexine distinctly overlapping
the ora. Its sexine patterns are striate to striato-reticulate or the
tectum is provided with spinules or is punctate. Comastoma
has pollen grains resembling those of Lomatogonium p. p.
and Halenia. The ora are lolongate to lalongate and relatively
large with lateral extensions. The sexine patterns are reticulate
with the bacula regularly arranged or with the bacula arranged
in no particular order, sometimes interconnected by thin con-
nections. It seems likely that further study of the group, using
the scanning electron microscope, will provide more taxon-
omically valuable pollen characters. Nilsson's (1967, 1976)
work is an example of the sort of studies that are needed.
Key to the genera in subtribe Gentianinae
la. Glands in a whorl attached to the base of the ovary:
2a. Corolla with plicae between the lobes (except in Gentiana
CLASSIFICATION OF GENTIAN A
171
luted), divided to less than halfway, the tube much longer than
the lobes, rarely divided to more than halfway and the tube
shorter than, or equalling, the lobes:
3a. Plants not climbing, with quadrangular, erect or ascending
stems Gentiana
3b. Plants climbing, with terete, twisted stems:
4a. Vascular bundles in calyx-tube 5; glands conspicuously
developed, forming a collar-like disc covering the base
of the ovary; stamens asymmetrical, unequal in length,
unilaterally and uniformly curved downwards at the apex,
the filaments linear or filiform; fruit a capsule or berry . . .
Tripterospermum
4b. Vascular bundles in calyx-tube 10; glands small, not
discoid; stamens symmetrical, equal in length, straight,
the filaments thickened below; fruit a capsule
Crawfurdia
2b. Corolla without plicae between the lobes, divided to more
than halfway, the tube shorter than, or equalling, the lobes:
5a. Ovary sub-bilocular, with a lamellate intrusion of the
placenta into the locular cavity Ixanthus
5b. Ovary unilocular, without a lamellate intrusion of the
placenta into the locular cavity:
6a. Stamens inserted on the sinus of the corolla-lobes;
capsule twisted above; flowers small Latouchea
6b. Stamens inserted on the upper part of the corolla-
tube; capsule straight; flowers large Megacodon
Ib. Glands in foveae, lobes or spurs attached to corolla-tube and
alternating with the stamens:
la. Corolla with spurs at the base of the corolla-tube, rarely
spurless; glands prolonged into the spurs Halenia
7b. Corolla without spurs; foveae on corolla-tube or on lobes:
8a. Corolla usually tubular, the tube longer than the lobes,
less often the tube shorter than, or as long as, the lobes:
9a. Buds large, slightly flattened, 4-angled; pairs of calyx-
lobes dissimilar, one longer and narrower than the
other; corolla frequently fringed or toothed; seeds
angular-papillose Gentianopsis
9b. Buds small, not flattened; calyx-lobes usually all
similar; corolla not fringed; seeds almost smooth:
lOa. Corolla bearing two evascular fimbriate scales at
the base of each lobe Comastoma
lOb. Corolla naked at the throat or bearing vascular
fimbriae, the fimbriae united into a single scale
extending across the base of each lobe (Gentianella):
lla. Stems twining; calyx conspicuously 4-winged;
seeds discoid-winged Pterygocalyx
lib. Stems erect; calyx unwinged; seeds unwinged:
12a. Corolla imbricate in bud; stamens inserted at,
or below, the middle of the corolla-tube; seeds
generally numerous per capsule .... Gentianella
12b. Corolla valvate in bud; stamens inserted on the
sinus between the lobes; seeds few per capsule
Jaeschkea
8b. Corolla rotate, the tube much shorter than the lobes:
13a. Dioecious, with unisexual flowers; stamens inserted on
the sinus between the corolla-lobes Veratrilla
13b. Flowers hermaphrodite; stamens inserted on the corolla-
tube:
14a. Style present, the stigmas never decurrent; corolla-
lobes concolorous Swertia
14b. Style absent, the stigmas decurrent along the ventral
suture of the ovary; corolla-lobes conspicuously bi-
colorous, half pale and half dark:
15a. Corolla- lobes bearing conspicuous foveae which
are sometimes connate below into a tube, but
lobed or lamellate above Lomatogonium
15b. Corolla-lobes efoveolate, bearing appendages
which are lamellate or galeate, and entire or erose
Lomatogoniopsis
INFRAGENERIC CLASSIFICATION
Some 40 botanists have studied Gentiana intensively since
Linnaeus formally established the genus. They not only
discovered large numbers of new species, but they have also
treated the genus in a wide variety of ways. The taxonomic
history has been well documented by Kusnezow (1894) and
Gillet (1957), and will therefore not be repeated here in
detail. The discussion that follows will just review some of the
more important works.
In 1737, when Linnaeus took up Tournefort's Gentiana he
divided the genus into seven groups. In 1753, he redivided it
less successfully into three unnamed sections, describing 23
species, of which the first, G. lutea L., has been taken as the
type species of Gentiana by later authors.
Froelich (1796) was the first to monograph Gentiana, and
split the genus into four groups of uncertain rank: Coelanthe,
Calathianae, Endotrichae, and Crossopetalae, with 47 species
altogether.
Grisebach's monographic study of Gentianaceae is one of
the landmarks of work on the family. In Genera et species
Gentianearum (1838) he divided the genus into seven sections
with 125 species. In his treatment of Gentianaceae in De
Candolle's Prodromus (1845) he redivided it into 15 sections, of
which seven (Asterias, Coelanthe, Pneumonanthe, Tretorrhiza,
Chondrophyllae, Thylacites, Cyclostigma, and Eurythalia}
belong to Gentiana sensu stricto, and increased the number of
species to 153.
Kusnezow's monograph of Gentiana subgenus Eugentiana
(1894) and his treatment of Gentiana in Engler & Prantl's Die
naturlichen Pflanzenfamilien (1895) provided the generally
accepted basis for the division of Gentiana into sections. His
subgenus Eugentiana corresponds to Gentiana sensu stricto as
a genus, and was divided into 10 sections (Coelanthe,
Pneumonanthe, Stenogyne, Frigida, Aptera, Chondrophyllae,
Otophora, Isomeria, Thylacites, and Cyclostigma}, with 162
species.
Marquand published several papers from 1928 to 1937,
notably his revision of the Chinese species of Gentiana
(1937a). He usefully subdivided some sections into series,
e.g. Otophora into ser. Otophorae and Decoratae; Frigida
into ser. Verticillatae, Omatae, Suborbisepalae, Confertifoliae,
Uniflorae, Sikkimenses, Multiflorae, and Annuae; and
Chondrophyllae into ser. Pubigerae, Fimbriatae, Orbiculatae,
Linearifoliae, Rubicundae, and Humiles; and included 163
species from China (excepting sect. Dipterospermum and
sect. Tripterospermum), of which 34 were new. Grisebach's
and Kusnezow's revisions contained only 71 and 162 species
respectively of Gentiana sensu stricto for the whole world.
However, Marquand combined the genera Crawfurdia and
Tripterospermum with Gentiana as two additional sections
and relegated Pterygocalyx to Gentianella, which had been
excluded from Gentiana by him in an earlier paper (1931).
In 1936, Smith raised Hemsley's sect. Megacodon to
generic rank and almost thirty years later (in 1965) he
reinstated Crawfurdia and Tripterospermum as two indepen-
dent genera. In 1961, when Smith studied the Gentiana
172
cachemirica group he subdivided sect. Frigida into two sub-
sections: Monopodiae and Sympodiae, based on differences
of branching. This is a very important character in perennial
Gentiana, which attracted the attention of Serebryakova
(1979), who demonstrated the basic models of shoot forma-
tion and indicated various evolutionary trends in the genus.
This character is further discussed in the present paper.
Ma (1951) segregated sect. Crossopetalum from Gentiana
as a separate genus, Gentianopsis.
In a series of papers published between 1967 and 1979,
Pringle not only monographed sect. Pneumonanthe and sect.
Chondrophyllae of eastern North America, central America
and Mexico, but also made a careful and clear revision of the
sectional and subsectional names.
In the present paper, Gentiana is split into 15 sections. Five
of these are further divided into a number of series. This
classification essentially agrees with that of Kusnezow's
monograph, but includes several significant changes. It is
based on Ho (1985), in which three new sections (Phyllocalyx,
Microsperma, and Dolichocarpd) and five new series (Stragu-
latae, Capitatae, Fastigiatae, Napuliferae, and Piasezkianae)
were proposed, and subsect. Monopodiae was raised to
sectional rank. These treatments are supported chiefly by
different branching patterns of the stem, various structures of
the testa, the presence or absence of a wing on the capsule,
features of the calyx, etc. Here we reinstate Grisebach's sect.
Eurythalia, which has been forgotten for about a century and
a half, as a section, but under a new name, Fimbricorona.
This section is very unusual in Gentiana and its fimbriate
corona borne at the throat of the corolla reminds one of the
genus Comastoma. In addition we describe two new series
(ser. Coriaceae T.N. Ho and ser. Grandiflorae Grossh. ex
T.N. Ho) and make one new combination, ser. Monanthae
(H. Smith) T.N. Ho, in sect. Monopodiae T.N. Ho. This is a
revision of the arrangement in Ho et al. (1988).
TAXONOMIC CHARACTERS
This section deals with those characters used in the infra-
generic classification that need explanation.
1. GROWTH HABIT. All species of Gentiana are herbs, varying
from dwarf plants, only one or a few centimetres high, to tall,
robust plants up to 120 cm high (G. luted). About half of the
species are annuals belonging to five sections; the other half
are perennials and belong to 10 sections.
2. ROOTS. The roots of Gentiana are of four types related to
the growth habit and the branching of the stems: fibrous
roots, fleshy stout tap-roots, fleshy linear-cylindrical roots,
and rhizomes or stolons with adventitious roots. The first type
is the commonest, the roots being fibrous or even woody. The
primary root is rather small but slightly thickened, forming a
slender tap-root with few secondary rootlets. This type
is found in the annual sections, i.e. Chondrophyllae,
Dolichocarpa, Microsperma, Stenogyne, and Fimbricorona.
The second type is confined to sect. Otophora, in which the
plant has a fleshy, stout cylindrical or fusiform, persistent tap-
root and a few smaller secondary rootlets. The third type, in
which the plant has several to many fleshy, linear-cylindrical
roots arising from the collar, is confined to sect. Monopodiae
and sect. Cruciata. The last type, as the second and third, is
T.-N. HO&S.-W. LIU
always associated with branching of the stem, the plants
having rhizomes or stolons with adventitious roots from the
nodes. This type is found in the majority of perennial
sections, i.e. Pneumonanthe, Gentiana, Phyllocalyx, Isomeria,
Frigida, Ciminalis, and Calathianae.
3. STEM AND BRANCHING. The stem is always erect or ascending,
terete, with striae or angles, sometimes having a conspicuous
caudex at the base. This is most conspicuous in sect. Cruciata,
where the plant has a stout caudex sheathed by fibrous old
petioles enabling this section to be recognized at a glance.
Sect. Monopodiae ser. Monanthae also has a stout caudex but
differs from sect. Cruciata in the caudex being sheathed by
membranous old petioles. In all the other groups the caudex
is indistinct. In the perennial groups, the branching of the
stem is a very constant and significant feature, and provides a
reliable diagnostic character for the definition and grouping
of sections and series. There are two main types as follows
(Fig. 1):
A. Monopodial branching. The plant consists of a basal
rosette with a terminal bud (growing point of the plant axis)
sunk in it. This terminal bud has great vitality and can grow
continuously, lasting throughout the life of the plant. The
flowering stems are produced each year from the axillary buds
of the basal leaves of the rosette. This monopodial branching
type falls into two subtypes:
a. Perennial flowering stems. The basal rosette is poorly
defined, with a few small, linear-triangular leaves. The
flowering stems grow continually and can last for several
years. This subtype is confined to sect. Otophora ser.
Decoratae.
b. Annual flowering stems. The basal rosette is well-
defined, with abundant large leaves. The flowering stems only
last for one year. This subtype is confined to sect. Monopodiae,
sect. Cruciata, and sect. Otophora ser. Otophorae.
B. Sympodial branching. In contrast to monopodial branch-
ing, in which the growing point is apical and everlasting, the
growing point in sympodial branching is lateral and constantly
renewed. The plant has rhizomes or stolons, which have
nodes, internodes, buds and adventitious roots, but no basal
rosette. After a time, growth of the terminal bud slows down
and stops, at which the buds on the nodes grow out instead.
The flowering shoots are produced annually from buds on the
nodes of the rhizomes or stolons, as well as from the apex of
the stolons. Sympodial branching is undoubtedly, as has often
been explained, more advanced evolutionarily than mono-
podial branching. Because the terminal bud dies and the
lateral buds renew the growth, the plant can produce progres-
sively more and more lateral buds to prodice a more
luxuriant form. The sympodial branching of Gentiana exhibits
two subtypes as follows:
a. Rhizome subtype. The rhizome is usually stout, fleshy
and horizontal or ascending, or more rarely vertical under the
ground. Adventitious roots and a lateral rosette arise first
from a node and then buds in the axils of the outer leaves of
the lateral rosette give rise to the flowering stems. This
subtype is found in sect. Frigida, sect. Gentiana, and some
species of sect. Pneumonanthe. However, most other species
of sect. Pneumonanthe are somewhat different from this
model in that the plants have no rosette and the buds of the
nodes give rise to the flowering stems directly.
b. Stolon subtype. This subtype is rather similar to the
Fig. 1 Types of stem branching (diagrammatic). 1-2 monopodial branching, 1. perennial flowering stem: G. decorate; 2. annual flowering
stem: G. veitchiorum. 3-5 sympodial branching: 3-4 rhizome subtype, 3. G. scabra; 4. G. algida; 5. stolon subtype: G. depressa var. stenophylla.
174
rhizome subtype but differs in having overground stolons and
runners. The stolons produce runners from the nodes and
these runners are ultimately terminated by a lateral rosette
with a few small leaves. The central bud of this rosette in time
produces the flowering stems. This subtype is the commoner,
being found in sect. Isomeria, sect. Phyllocalyx, sect.
Ciminalis, and sect. Calathianae.
4. LEAVES. The leaves are usually opposite, but in sect.
Monopodiae ser. Verticillatae they are in whorls of 3-8,
surrounding the 5-8-merous flowers. The leaves are generally
very variable in shape and size so that their taxonomic use is
limited, but in sect. Chondrophyllae leaf shape may be used
for the definition of series and species. Ser. Linear if oliae, for
example, is notable for its linear leaves.
5. INFLORESCENCE AND FLOWERS. The inflorescence is always
a cyme. The cyme may be simple, with 1-3 flowers, and this
may be reduced to a single terminal flower, sometimes also
with a few flowers in the axils of the uppermost leaves. This is
the commonest condition, occurring in almost all the annual
sections (except ser. Capitatae and some species of sect.
Chondrophyllae) and in some of the perennial groups. The
inflorescence may also be a complex cyme with few to many
flowers. The flowers are crowded and either pedicellate in
terminal and axillary cymes or sessile in terminal clusters, and
sometimes also in few-flowered axillary whorls. This condi-
tion is found in sect. Gentiana, sect. Pneumonanthe, sect.
Cruciata, etc.
6. CALYX. The calyx-tube is usually entirely tubular, but in
sect. Gentiana and some species of sect. Cruciata and sect.
Frigida it is split down one side to the middle or to near the
base, forming a spathe with small irregular teeth (Fig. 2). The
calyx-lobes are mostly triangular, ovate or lanceolate, but in
some groups other shapes occur: spathulate or suborbicular
and much narrowed at the base in sect. Isomeria ser. Stragulatae
and sect. Microsperma ser. Suborbisepalae; ovate and con-
tracted at the base in sect. Chondrophyllae ser. Orbiculatae;
filiform in sect. Chondrophyllae ser. Rubicundae; and subulate
with wide bases and acute apices in sect. Chondrophyllae ser.
Fimbriatae. The midribs are distinct, but the degree of
development varies considerably. The most prominent mid-
ribs are those forming keeled ribs on the outer face which are
decurrent into the angles or wings of the calyx-tube. This
condition is found in sect. Stenogyne, sect. Dolichocarpa,
sect. Calathianae, and sect. Microsperma ser. Tetramerae.
1. COROLLA. The corolla is important diagnostically and
provides a number of characters for the definition of species.
It varies in size from 3 mm to 70 mm, although the range is
usually relatively restricted and constant within each group.
Large corollas are 4-7 cm long, medium-sized ones 2.5-4 cm,
and small ones 0.3-2.5 cm. In general, all perennial sections
and the annual sect. Stenogyne have large or medium-sized
corollas, whereas the others (all the annual sections except
Stenogyne) have small corollas. The corolla is usually 5-lobed,
but 6-8-lobed corollas are found in sect. Monopodiae ser.
Verticillatae and in various species of the other sections. In
general, the corolla-tube is longer than the lobes, but the
reverse condition occurs in sect. Gentiana and sect.
Otophora, in which the corolla is divided to the middle or
near the base so that the corolla-tube is as long as, or much
shorter than, the lobes. The shape of the corolla varies
considerably and the terms used to describe it in this paper
are as follows (Fig. 2):
T.-N. HO &S. -W.LIU
Tubular. The corolla is tubular throughout, with slightly
divergent lobes.
Obconical. The corolla-tube is narrowed at the base but
gradually widened upwards with patent lobes.
Hypocrateriform. The corolla has a long, narrow, parallel-
sided tube and broad flat lobes spreading at right angles to the
tube.
Infundibuliform. The corolla-tube is narrowed in the lower
part but is gradually widened upwards, with erect-patent
lobes.
Campanulate. The corolla has a short, broad, parallel-sided
tube and patent lobes.
Urniform. The corolla-tube is very inflated in the middle but
contracted below and in the throat, with patent lobes.
These corolla shapes are not entirely clear-cut, and transitional
forms, which need not be discussed here, do occur.
The plicae of the corolla apparently exist in all species of
Gentiana except G. lutea, in which their absence is a particu-
larly diagnostic character. There are various degrees of
development of the plicae in the different groups (Fig. 2). In
sect. Gentiana and sect. Otophora the poorly developed
plicae are very small, asymmetrical and auriculate, whereas in
sect. Chondrophyllae and sect. Dolichocarpa the well-
developed plicae are large and symmetrical. These two types
represent the two extremes, the plicae of the other sections
being more or less intermediate. The margins of the plicae
vary from entire, erose, serrate, lacinulate or fimbriate to
setose-fimbriate. Sect. Chondrophyllae ser. Fimbriatae is
notable in that the corolla has fimbriate plicae.
8. STAMENS. The stamens are equal in number to the corolla-
lobes and alternate with them. They are generally 5 in
number, but in some species of sect. Monopodiae ser.
Verticillatae (where the flowers are 6-8-merous and the leaves
are in whorls of 6-8) they are 6-8. The great majority of
species have uniform stamens with more or less winged
filaments and free anthers, but in some species of sect.
Pneumonanthe and sect. Gentiana the anthers are contiguous.
9. PISTIL. The ovary, which is markedly uniform in general
structure, varies mainly in size. It is usually oblong or
elliptical and narrowed into the style, or the style may be
absent. The style is shortly cylindrical to narrowly linear,
much shorter than the ovary in most species, but in sect.
Stenogyne and a few other species (e.g. G. filistyla Balf. f. &
Forrest ex Marquand, G. tubiflora (G. Don) Wallich ex
Griseb., and G. vernayi Marquand) the style and stigmas are
very long and filiform, equalling, or only slightly shorter than,
the elongate ovary. The stigma-lobes in most sections are
uniformly oblong or linear and are free and recurved. How-
ever, in a few sections they depart from this norm and the
stigma-lobes are expanded and rounded, and either fimbriate
on the surface and contiguous into a small disc or infundibuli-
form structure but free after anthesis, or almost smooth and
either connate into a small disc or infundibuliform structure
and not free after anthesis, or contiguous into a small disc or
infundibuliform structure and free after anthesis. The first
condition is found in sect. Ciminalis, the second in sect.
Calathianae, and the third in sect. Phyllocalyx. These ex-
panded stigmas are diagnostic in Gentiana and form the most
important character separating the three sections. The gyno-
phore may elongate and become more apparent with age. In
some species the pistil is sessile or subsessile, but in others the
gynophore may be short in the young flower and elongate
Fig. 2 Calyx, corolla and plica shapes. 1-6 calyx types, 1. calyx-tube split down one side to the lower part to form a spathe with small teeth: G.
straminea; 2-6 calyx-lobe types, 2. filiform: G. rubicunda; 3. linear: G. dolichocalyx; 4. suborbicular: G. tongolensis; 5. ovate: G. squarrosa; 6.
triangular: G. pseudoaquatica. 7-12 corolla types, 7. tubular: G. prolata; 8. hypocrateriform: G. brachyphylla; 9. infundibuliform: G. farreri;
10. campanulate: G. alpina; 11. urniform: G. urnula; 12. rotate: G. lutea. 13-18 plica types, 13. plica absent: G. lutea; 14. truncate: G.
hexaphylla; 15. oblique: G. striata; 16. auriculate: G. doxiongshanensis; 17. symmetrical: G. pseudoaquatica; 18. fimbriate: G. panthaica.
176
T.-N. HO&S.-W. LIU
Fig. 3 SEM micrographs of seed types. 1-4 seeds with reticulately thickened testa, winged: 1-2 seeds surrounded by a discoid wing, 1 . G. lutea;
2. G. asclepiadea; 3. seed with wing on one side: G. pudica; 4. seed with wing at one end: G. bavarica. 5. seed with minutely reticulate testa,
triquetrous with the three edges winged: G. striata. 6. seed covered with membranous lamellae which form spongy complex pits: G. algida. (nos
1, 2, 5, 6, scale = 250 urn; nos 3, 4, scale = 50 urn)
considerably as the capsule matures. It seems that the gyno-
phore is of less taxonomic significance than the style or
stigma.
10. CAPSULE. The capsule is usually long and narrow, oblong
or cylindrical, and unwinged, but in sect. Chondrophyllae and
sect. Fimbricorona it is short and wide, obovoid or ellipsoid-
oblong, strongly compressed, and rounded at the apex with a
conspicuous broad wing which is narrowed towards the base.
11. SEEDS. There are six different seed types in the genus
(Figs 3-4):
a. The seed has a reticulately thickened testa, with either a
discoid wing or with a wing on one side or at one end of the
CLASSIFICATION OF GENTIANA
seed. This type is found in sect. Gentiana and sect.
Pneumonanthe, although some species of sect. Stenogyne
scarcely differ, their seeds having a minutely reticulate testa
and being triquetrous with the three edges winged.
b. The seed varies from almost smooth to distinctly reticulate
and is unwinged. This type is the commonest, being found
mainly in sect. Chondrophyllae, sect. Dolichocarpa, sect.
Cruciata, sect. Otophora, and sect. Calathianae.
c. The seed is covered with membranous lamellae which
177
form spongy, complex hexagonal pits. This type is confined to
sect. Frigida and some species of sect. Isomeria.
d. The seed is covered with membranous lamellae which
form honeycomb-like, simple, shallow, hexagonal pits. This
type occurs in sect. Monopodiae, sect. Microsperma, and
some species of sect. Isomeria.
e. Like d but the body of the seed is surrounded by a broad
wing. This type is found only in sect. Phyllocalyx.
f. The seed has a minutely and densely reticulate testa and
Fig. 4 SEM micrographs of seed types. 1-2 seeds covered with membranous lamellae which form honeycomb-like simple pits, 1 . G. farreri; 2.
G. 'tubiflora. 3-4 seeds minutely reticulate, 3. G. leucomelaena; 4. G. straminea. 5-6 seeds with minutely and densely reticulate testa, rugose, 5.
G. alpina; 6. G. clusii. (nos 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, scale = 250 urn; no. 3, scale = 50 urn)
178
is rugose and unwinged. This type is confined to sect.
Ciminalis.
These seed characters are certainly diagnostically important.
However, the different types do sometimes occur in the same
section, for instance, a, b, and d all occur in sect. Stenogyne, a
very natural group in general appearance; c and d both occur
in sect. Isomeria, a stoloniferous group. Seed characters must
therefore not be relied on too heavily, as Kusnezow and
Marquand did when delimiting sections. Seed structure is,
however, constant within species and may therefore be used
for defining species, as well as for the partial delimitation of
some sections (e.g. Cruciata, Chondrophyllae, Microsperma,
etc.).
SYSTEMATIC TREATMENT
Gentiana (Tourn., Inst. rei herb.: 80, t. 40 (1700) )L., Gen.
pi. : 69 (1737); Sp. pi. : 227 (1753). Type species: G. lutea L.
Subgen. Eugentiana Kusn. in Trudy imp. S.-Peterb. Obshch.
Estest. 24(2): 3 (1894).
Annual or perennial herbs. Roots fibrous with a primary root
and secondary rootlets, or slightly fleshy and forming a stout
tap-root with secondary rootlets, or several linear-cylindrical
roots from the collar. Stem erect or ascending, striate and
angled, simple or branched, in perennial species sometimes
both flowering stem and vegetative stems present; rhizomes
or stolons present or absent. Leaves opposite, rarely verticil-
late, sometimes forming a rosette at the base of the stem.
Cyme simple with 1-3 flowers, or complex with few many
flowers, the flowers pedicellate in terminal and axillary cymes
or sessile in terminal clusters or sometimes also in few-
flowered axillary whorls; flowers usually 5-merous, rarely 4-
or 6-8-merous; calyx-tube with a continuous or undeveloped
intracalycular membrane, the lobes triangular, ovate or filiform,
with prominent midribs; corolla tubular, infundibuliform,
obconical, hypocrateriform, or urniform, very rarely rotate,
usually lobed, the tube much shorter than the lobes, or rarely
the tube as long as or longer than the lobes, plicate between
the lobes (except in G. lutea L.); stamens alternate with the
corolla-lobes, the filaments more or less winged, the anthers
basifixed, free or rarely contiguous; ovary oblong or elliptic;
style often short, cylindrical or linear, less often long
and filiform, longer or slightly shorter than the ovary, the
stigma-lobes usually oblong to linear, free, recurved, rarely
expanded and rounded, connate or contiguous into a small
disc or infundibuliform structure; glands 5-10, at the base of
the ovary, the pistil sessile or with an elongate gynophore.
Capsule oblong or cylindrical and unwinged, or obovoid and
winged; seeds numerous, small, minutely reticulate, rugose,
simply areolate or with complex spongy areolation, winged or
unwinged.
DISTRIBUTION. Europe, Asia, America, NW. Africa (Morocco),
E. Australia.
Fifteen sections, 361 species.
Key to the sections
la. Perennials, with thick, slightly fleshy roots, rarely annuals with
fibrous roots (G. nivalis and G. utriculosa); flowers large (4-7 cm
long) or medium-sized (2.5^4 cm long); capsule unwinged:
T.-N. HO&S.-W. LIU
2a. Branching monopodial, the plant with a basal rosette with a
terminal bud sunk in it, the flowering stems arising annually
from the axillary buds of the rosette leaves:
3a. Corolla usually divided to the middle or below, the tube
shorter than, or equalling, the lobes; plicae small, auricu-
late; plant with a stout, cylindrical or fusiform tap-root
I. Sect. Otophora
3b. Corolla always divided to less than halfway, the tube much
longer than the lobes; plicae large, triangular to truncate;
plant with thickened, linear-cylindrical roots from the collar:
4a. Caudex with a fibrous sheath of brown remains of petioles;
roots usually contiguous and twisted into a stout, cylindri-
cal mass; seeds minutely but distinctly reticulate
II. Sect. Cruciata
4b. Caudex without a fibrous sheath of remains of petioles;
roots laxly divergent; seeds covered with honeycomb-like,
hexagonal, simple, shallow pits .... III. Sect. Monopodiae
2b. Branching sympodial, the plant with rhizomes or stolons with
nodes, internodes, membranous scales, buds, and adventitious
roots, but without a basal rosette with a terminal bud, the
flowering stems arising annually from the buds at the nodes or
apices of the rhizomes or stolons:
5a. Plants with a stout, slightly fleshy, horizontal or ascending,
rarely vertical, underground rhizome, or the rhizome some-
times abbreviated but conspicuous:
6a. Seeds covered with membranous lamellae which form
spongy, hexagonal complex pits, unwinged
IV. Sect. Frigida
6b. Seeds without membranous lamellae, but with a thick-
ened, reticulate testa, winged with either a discoid wing or
with a wing on one side or at one end of the seed, or rarely
unwinged:
7a. Plants with lateral rosettes which arise from the nodes
of the rhizome; flowering stems arising from the axils of
the lateral rosette-leaves, without scale-like leaves at
the base; corolla lobed to below the middle or to near
the base; 5-9-lobed, the plicae very small, auriculate
(absent in G. lutea) V. Sect. Gentiana
7b. Plants without lateral rosettes; flowering stems arising
directly from the nodes of the rhizome, usually with
scale-like leaves below; corolla lobed to less than half-
way, 5-lobed, the plicae large, obliquely truncate or
triangular VI. Sect. Pneumonanthe
5b. Plants with stolons and runners creeping on the surface:
8a. Stigma-lobes not expanded, linear or oblong, free
and recurved X. Sect. Isomeria
8b. Stigma-lobes expanded, connate or contiguous into a
small disc or infundibuliform structure:
9a. Calyx very small, completely enveloped by the upper-
most pair of broad, obovate, obtuse leaves; seeds
broadly winged, covered with honeycomb-like, hex-
agonal, simple, shallow pits VII. Sect. Phyllocalyx
9b. Calyx large, not enveloped by the uppermost pair of
leaves; seeds unwinged:
lOa. Corolla hypocrateriform; calyx-tube prominently
angled or winged; stigma-lobes almost smooth, con-
nate into a disc or infundibuliform structure, not
free after anthesis; seeds not rugose
VIII. Sect. Calathianae
lOb. Corolla obconical; calyx-tube unwinged; stigma-
lobes fimbriate on the surface, contiguous into a disc
or infundibuliform structure, but free after anthesis;
seeds rugose IX. Sect. Ciminalis
Ib. Annuals, with fibrous roots; flowers small (0.3-2.5 cm long),
or rarely large or medium-sized; rarely perennials with small
flowers; capsule winged or unwinged:
CLASSIFICATION OF GENTIAN A
179
lla. Capsule obovoid or ellispoid-oblong, rounded at the apex,
conspicuously winged, the wing strong and broad at the apex
but gradually narrowed towards the base; basal leaves longer
than the cauline; cauline leaves all more or less equal in size:
12a. Corolla naked in the throat . . . XIV. Sect. Chondrophyllae
12b. Corolla with a corona of multicellular hairs in the throat . . .
XV. Sect. Fimbricorona
lib. Capsule cylindrical to narrowly oblong, obtuse or attenuate
at the apex, unwinged; basal leaves small; cauline leaves
usually decreasing in size towards the base of the stem:
13a. Seeds covered with honeycomb-like, hexagonal, simple,
shallow pits; calyx usually not keeled or winged (if strongly
winged, then ser. Tetramerae flowers 4-merous)
XI. Sect. Microsperma
13b. Seeds with minute or thickened reticulation; calyx keeled
or winged:
14a. Flowers large or medium-sized; plicae obliquely
asymmetrical; style filiform, longer or slightly shorter
than the ovary; capsule enclosed in the corolla; seeds
usually winged XII. Sect. Stenogyne
14b. Flowers small; plicae symmetrical; style much shorter
than the ovary; capsule exserted from the corolla; seeds
usually unwinged XIII. Sect. Dolichocarpa
Keys to the series
Sect. Otophora Kusn.
la. Basal rosette well-developed, with abundant large leaves; flower-
ing stems annual; cauline leaves few, distant . . 1 . Ser. Otophorae
Ib. Basal rosette poorly developed, with few small leaves; flowering
stems perennial; cauline leaves numerous, crowded
2. Ser. Decoratae
Sect. Monopodiae (H. Smith) T.N. Ho
la. Vegetative axis sometimes prolonged and branched, with several
basal rosettes decumbent on the ground; flowers several in a
terminal inflorescence 4. Ser. Apteroideae
Ib. Vegetative axis not prolonged, with one basal rosette decumbent
on the ground; flowers sometimes solitary and terminal:
2a. Caudex with a brown membranous sheath of old petioles;
leaves broad; leaves and calyx-lobes with conspicuous carti-
laginous margins 1 . Ser. Monanthae
2b. Caudex without a sheath of old petioles; leaves narrow; leaves
and calyx-lobes without cartilaginous margins:
3a. Leaves in whorls of 3-8; flowers 5-8-merous
2. Ser. Verticillatae
3b. Leaves opposite; flowers 5-merous 3. Ser. Ornatae
Sect. Isomeria Kusn.
la. Flowers several together in an inflorescence; petioles of upper
cauline leaves of flowering stems conspicuously broadened
1 . Ser. Sikkimenses
Ib. Flowers typically solitary and terminal; petioles not broadened:
2a. Leaves and calyx-lobes with conspicuous, wide, membranous
or cartilaginous margins 2. Ser. Depressae
2b. Leaves and calyx-lobes without membranous or cartilaginous
margins:
3a. Calyx-lobes orbicular-spathulate, narrowed at the base into
a tongue 3. Ser. Stragulatae
3b. Calyx-lobes narrowly elliptical or triangular, not narrowed
at the base 4. Ser. Uniflorae
Sect. Microsperma T.N. Ho
la. Leaves and calyx-lobes spathulate; flowers small; gynoecium and
stamens usually exserted from the corolla
1 . Ser. Suborbisepalae
Ib. Leaves and calyx-lobes not spathulate; flowers medium-sized;
gynoecium and stamens included in the corolla:
2a. Flowers 4-merous; calyx-lobes with strongly keeled midribs
which are decurrent below into conspicuous broad wings
2. Ser. Tetramerae
2b. Flowers 5-merous; calyx unwinged 3. Ser. Annuae
Sect. Chondrophyllae Bunge
la. Capsule narrowly elliptical, attenuate or obtuse at the apex:
2a. Annuals; flowers 25-36 mm long; calyx-lobes with strongly
keeled midribs which are decurrent below into conspicuous
wings; corolla hypocrateriform 10. Ser. Piasezkianae
2b. Perennials; flowers 40-55 mm long; calyx-lobes without keeled
midribs; corolla infundibuliform 11. Ser. Grandiflorae
Ib. Capsule obovoid, spathulate or oblong, rounded or trun-
cate at the apex; calyx-lobes not keeled; corolla tubular or
infundibuliform:
3a. Annuals:
4a. Calyx-lobes usually very narrow, filiform or filiform-
subulate:
5a. Plicae usually fimbriate, rarely dentate; leaves and calyx
densely and minutely papillose 1 . Ser. Fimbriatae
5b. Plicae entire or denticulate; leaves and calyx glabrous,
smooth 2. Ser. Rubicundae
4b. Calyx-lobes broad, triangular or lanceolate:
6a. Stems ascending or decumbent, usually branched from
the base, without a conspicuous main stem, rarely
unbranched:
7a. Cauline leaves mostly long and very narrow, more or
less linear or subulate 3. Ser. Linearifoliae
7b. Cauline leaves short and broad, not linear or subulate:
8a. Calyx-lobes recurved or patent, rarely erect, ovate or
orbicular, rarely lanceolate, contracted at the base . .
4. Ser. Orbiculatae
8b. Calyx-lobes erect, triangular or lanceolate, not
contracted at the base 5. Ser. Humiles
6b. Stems erect, with a conspicuous main stem, branched or
rarely simple:
9a. Stems simple, densely papillose, winged or angled,
leafless in the lower half; much branched in the upper
half, with abbreviated internodes, numerous leaves and
flowering branches, all congested at the apex of the
stem into a subcapitate inflorescence . 6. Ser. Capitatae
9b. Stems almost glabrous, unwinged, fastigiately branched
from the base or the middle, with elongated internodes,
the branches lax and more or less corymbosely disposed
7. Ser. Fastigiatae
3b. Perennials:
lOa. Roots rather fleshy; leaves herbaceous
8. Ser. Napuliferae
lOb. Roots fibrous; leaves coriaceous 9. Ser. Coriaceae
CLASSIFICATION
I. Sect. Otophora Kusn. in Engl. & Prantl, Nat. Pflanzenfam.
4(2): 82 (1895). Type species: G. Otophora Franchet ex F.
B. Forbes & Hemsley.
Perennials, with a stout, cylindrical or fusiform, slightly fleshy
tap-root; branching monopodial; corolla usually lobed to the
middle or below, the tube shorter than, or equalling, the
lobes (except in G. doxiongshanensis T.N. Ho); plicae very
small, auriculate, attached on the right side of each lobe as
seen from within; seeds usually minutely reticulate, rarely
covered with honeycomb-like, hexagonal, simple, shallow
pits.
180
DISTRIBUTION. C. and E. Himalaya*, E. India (Assam), NE.
Burma, SW. Chinat-
Two series, 12 species.
1. Ser. Otophorae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R. hot. Gdns,
Kew for 1937: 152 (1937). Type species: G. otophora
Franchet ex F. B. Forbes & Hemsley.
Plants with well-developed basal rosette; flowering stems
annual.
DISTRIBUTION. As for the section.
Eight species.
2. Ser. Decoratae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R. hot. Gdns,
Kew for 1937: 152 (1937). Type species: G. decor ata Diels.
Plants with poorly developed basal rosettes; flowering stems
perennial.
DISTRIBUTION. As for the section.
Four species.
II. Sect. Cruciate Gaudin, Fl. helv. 2: 269 (1828). Type
species: G. cruciata L.
Sect. Erythaliae Bunge in Nouv. Mem. Soc. Imp. Nat. Mosc.
1(7): 207 (1829), non (Borkh.) Griseb. (1840). Type species:
G. cruciata L.
Sect. Tretorrhlza Griseb. in Hook., Fl. bor.-amer. 2: 60
(1837). Lectotype species: G. cruciata L.
Sect. Kurroo C. B. Clarke in J. Linn. Soc. (Bot). 14: 433
(1875). Type species: G. kurroo Royle.
Sect. Aptera Kusn. in Trudy imp. S.-Peterb. hot. Sada 13: 62
(1893). Lectotype species: G. biflora Regel.
Perennials; roots usually contiguous and twisted into a stout,
cylindrical structure; branching monopodial; caudex with a
brown, fibrous sheath of old petioles; basal rosette well-
developed, with large leaves; seeds minutely but distinctly
reticulate.
DISTRIBUTION. E., C., and S. Europe, U.S.S.R. European
part; W. Asia (Turkey, Iraq, Iran, Syria, Afghanistan), N.
and central part of Asia (Kashmir-Himalayan region, SW.
and N. China, U.S.S.R. (Caucasus, C. Asia, W. and E.
Siberia, Far East), Mongolia).
Twenty-one species.
III. Sect. Monopodiae (H. Smith) T.N.Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 10 (1985).
Subsect. Monopodiae H. Smith in Kew Bull. 15(1): 43 (1961).
Type species: G. cephalantha Franchet ex F. B. Forbes &
Hemsley.
Perennials; branching monopodial; seeds covered with
honeycomb-like, hexagonal, simple, shallow pits.
DISTRIBUTION. Kashmir-Himalayan region, Burma, NW.,
SW., C., S., and E. China, Japan, Thailand, Vietnam,
Malaya, Indonesia.
* Includes Nepal, Sikkim, Bhutan, and S. Tibet.
t The regions of China are NW.: Qinghai, Gansu, Shaanxi, Ningxia-Hui,
Xinjiang Uygur Zizhiqu; N.: Shanxi, Hebei, Nei Mongol Zizhiqu; NE.:
Heilongjiang, Jilin, Liaoning; C.: Henan, Hubei, Hunan; E.: Shandong,
Jiangsu, Anhui, Zhejiang, Jiangxi, Fujian, (and Taiwan); SW.: Tibet, Yunnan,
Guizhou, Sichuan; S.: Guangdong, Guangxi-Zhuang.
T.-N. HO&S.-W. LIU
Four series, 37 species.
1. Ser. Monanthae (H. Smith) T.N. Ho, comb. nov.
Sect. Frigida ser. Rosulatae subser. Monanthae H. Smith in
Kew Bull. 15(1): 54 (1961). Type species: G. szechenyii
Kanitz.
Caudex with a brown, membranous sheath of old petioles;
leaves broad; leaves and calyx-lobes both with conspicuous
cartilaginous margins.
DISTRIBUTION. Kashmir-Himalayan region, SW. and NW.
China.
Four species.
2. Ser. Vertidllatae (Marquand) T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 11(1985).
Kudoa Masam. in /. trop. Agric. 2: 29 (1930). Type species:
G. yakushimensis Makino.
Sect. Frigida ser. Vertidllatae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R.
hot. Gdns, Kew for 1937: 158 (1937). Type species: G.
hexaphylla Maxim, ex Kusn.
Sect. Kudoa (Masam.) Satake & Toyok. ex Toyok. in /. Jap.
Bot. 35: 202 (1960).
Sect. Frigida ser. Ornatae subser. Vertidllatae H. Smith in
Kew Bull. 15(1): 54 (1961). Type species: G. hexaphylla
Maxim, ex Kusn.
Leaves in whorls of 3-8, narrow; flowers solitary, terminal, 5-
8-merous.
DISTRIBUTION. China (SW. and NW. regions, except Xinjiang
Uygur Zizhiqu, Taiwan), Japan.
Eight species.
3. Ser. Ornatae (Marquand) T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 11 (1985).
Sect. Frigida ser. Ornatae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R.
hot. Gdns, Kew for 1937: 159 (1937). Type species: G. sino-
ornata Balf. f.
Sect. Frigida ser. Ornatae subser. Oppositifoliae H. Smith in
Kew Bull. 15(1): 54 (1961). Type species: G. sino-ornata
Balf. f.
Leaves opposite, narrow; flowers solitary, terminal, 5-merous.
DISTRIBUTION. C. & E. Himalayan region, Burma, SW. and
NW. China.
Sixteen species.
4. Ser. Apteroideae (H. Smith) T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 11(1985).
Sect. Frigida ser. Rosulatae subser. Apteroideae H. Smith in
Kew Bull. 15(1): 54 (1961). Type species: G. cephalantha
Franchet ex F. B. Forbes & Hemsley.
Vegetative stems sometimes prolonged and branched, with
several basal rosettes decumbent on the ground; flowers
several together in infloresences at the apex of the flowering
stems.
DISTRIBUTION. Burma, SW., C., E., and S. China, Thailand,
Vietnam, Malaya, Indonesia, Sabah.
Nine species.
CLASSIFICATION OF GENTIAN A
IV. Sect. Frigida Kusn. in Trudy imp. S.-Peterb. hot. Sada 13:
61 (1893). Type species: G. frigida Haenke.
Sect. Frigida subsect. Sympodiae ser. Algidae H. Smith in
Kew Bull. 15(1): 55 (1961). Type species: G. algida Pallas.
Favargera A. & D. Love in Bot. Notiser 125: 256 (1972). Type
species: F. froelichii (Kusn.) A. & D. Love.
Gentianodes A. & D. Love in Bot. Notiser 125: 256 (1972).
Type species: G. frigida Haenke.
Perennials; branching sympodial, the plants with a short
rhizome, 1-few non-flowering rosettes and 1-few flowering
stems; seeds covered with membranous lamellae which form
spongy, hexagonal, complex pits.
DISTRIBUTION. Europe (Alps, Carpathians, and SW. Bulgaria);
Asia (Kashmir-Himalayan region, SW., NW., and ME.
China, U.S.S.R. (Caucasus, C. Asia, W. and E. Siberia, Far
East), Mongolia, Korea, Japan); N. America (western part of
Canada and the United States).
Eighteen species.
V. Sect. Gentiana. Type species: G. lutea L.
Sect. Coelanthae Froelich, Gentiana: 15 (1796). Type species:
G. lutea L.
Sect. Gentianotypus Dumort., Fl. belg.: 51 (1827). Type
species: G. lutea L.
Sect. Asteria Gaudin, Fl. helv. 2: 269 (1828). Lectotype
species: G. lutea L.
Perennials; branching sympodial, the plants with a short,
stout rhizome, a non-flowering basal rosette, and a flowering
stem; corolla lobed to the middle or below, plicae very small,
auriculate, attached to the right side of each lobe as seen from
within, or absent (G. luted); seeds with thickened reticulate
testa, and a discoid wing.
DISTRIBUTION. C. and S. Europe and S. Norway; Turkey.
Five species.
VI. Sect. Pneumonanthe (Gled.) Gaudin, Fl. helv. 2: 269
(1828).
Pneumonanthe Gled., Syst. pi. stamin. situ: 238 (1764). Type
species: G. pneumonanthe L.
Gentiana Pneumonanthe Link, Enum. hort. berol. alt. 1:
258 (1821). Lectotype species: G. pneumonanthe L.
Subgen. Pneumonanthe Raf., Med. fl. 1: 208 (1828). Lecto-
type species: G. pneumonanthe L.
Sect. Cyane Griseb. in Hook., Fl. bor.-amer. 2: 54 (1837).
Type species: G. pneumonanthe L.
Perennials; branching sympodial, the plants with a rhizome
and 1-few flowering stems, but non-flowering basal rosettes
usually absent; flowering stems bearing scale-like leaves
below; seed with a reticulately thickened testa, usually
winged.
DISTRIBUTION. Much of Europe; N. and E. Asia; N. and C.
America.
Thirty-eight species.
VII. Sect. Phyllocalyx T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res. Harbin 5(4):
14 (1985). Type species: G. phyllocalyx C. B. Clarke.
Sect. Frigida p. Phyllocalyx Kusn. in Trudy imp. S.-Peterb.
hot. Sada 15: 287 (1898).
181
Perennials; branching sympodial, the plants with short
stolons; calyx very small, completely enveloped by the upper-
most pair of leaves; stigma-lobes expanded, contiguous into a
small disc or infundibuliform structure, but free after anthe-
sis; seeds with honeycomb-like, hexagonal, simple, shallow
pits, with a discoid wing.
DISTRIBUTION. C. and E. Himalayan region, mountains of
SW. China.
A monotypic section.
VIII. Sect. Calathianae Froelich, Gentiana: 57 (1796). Lecto-
type species: G. nivalis L.
Hippion F. W. Schmidt, Fl. boem. 2: 18 (1793). Type species:
H. aestivum F. W. Schmidt.
Sect. Ericoila Dumort., Fl. belg.: 51 (1827). Type species: G.
nivalis L.
Sect. Gentianella Gaudin, Fl. helv. 2: 270 (1828), non
Dumort. (1827). Lectotype species: G. nivalis L.
Sect. Hippion (F. W. Schmidt) Gaudin, Fl. helv. 2: 270
(1828).
Sect. Cydostigma Griseb., Gen. sp. Gent.: 259 (1838). Lecto-
type species: G. nivalis L.
Perennials, less often annuals; branching sympodial, the
plants with stolons and runners; calyx-tube prominently
angled or winged; corolla hypocrateriform; stigma-lobes
expanded, almost smooth on the surface, contiguous into a
disc or infundibuliform structure, but not free after anthesis;
seeds usually minutely reticulate, unwinged, rarely reticulately
thickened and with a wing at one end.
DISTRIBUTION. W., C., and S. Europe, U.S.S.R. (Arctic
European part); W. Asia (Turkey, Iran, Iraq), N. Asia
(U.S.S.R. (Caucasus, Altai), Mongolia); N. America
(Labrador, Greenland); Africa (Morocco).
Eight species.
IX. Sect. Ciminalis (Adans.) Dumort., Fl. belg.: 51 (1827).
Ciminalis Adans., Fam. pi. 2: 504 (1763). Lectotype species:
G. acaulis L.
Sect. Megalanthe Gaudin, Fl. helv. 2: 270 (1828). Lectotype
species: G. acaulis L.
Sect. Thylacites Griseb. in DC., Prodr. 9: 115 (1845). Lecto-
type species: G. acaulis L.
Perennials; branching sympodial, the plants with stolons and
runners; corolla obconical; stigma-lobes expanded, fimbriate
on the surface, contiguous into a small disc or infundibuliform
structure, free after anthesis; seeds rugose, with a minutely
reticulate testa.
DISTRIBUTION. C. and S. Europe.
Five species.
X. Sect. Isomeria Kusn. in Trudy imp. S.-Peterb. Obshch.
Estest. 24(2): 196 (1894). Lectotype species: G. depressa D.
Don.
Perennials; branching sympodial, the plants with stolons and
runners; stigma-lobes free, recurved, linear or oblong; seeds
with honeycomb-like, hexagonal, simple, shallow pits, rarely
with spongy, hexagonal, complex pits.
DISTRIBUTION. Asia (Kashmir-Himalayan region, NE. Burma,
182
SW., NW., and C. China, U.S.S.R. (E. Siberia, Far East),
Japan); N. America (western part of Canada and the United
States).
Four series, 18 species.
1. Ser. Sikkimenses (Marquand) T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 13 (1985).
Sect. Frigida ser. Sikkimenses Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf.
R. hot. Gdns, Kew for 1937: 162 (1937). Type species: G.
sikkimensis C. B. Clarke.
Leaves obovate, spathulate or oblong, rounded or obtuse at
the apex, petioles of cauline leaves gradually broadened
towards the top of the stem; flowers in fascicles of 3-8 in a
capitate infloresence.
DISTRIBUTION. As for the section, except NW. China.
Six species.
2. Ser. Depressae (H. Smith) T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 13 (1985).
Sect. Frigida ser. Confertifoliae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf.
R. hot. Gdns, Kew for 1937: 161 (1937). Type species: G.
confertifolia Marquand.
Sect. Frigida subsect. Sympodiae ser. Depressae H. Smith in
Kew Bull. 15(1): 55 (1961). Type species: G. depressa D.
Don.
Leaves and calyx-lobes with conspicuous cartilaginous mar-
gins; flowers usually solitary, terminal.
DISTRIBUTION. C. and E. Himalayan region, SW. and NW.
China.
Six species.
3. Ser. Stragulatae T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res. Harbin 5(4): 13
(1985). Type species: G. stragulata Balf. f. & Forrest ex
Marquand.
Calyx-lobes orbicular, spathulate, abruptly contracted at the
base into a tongue.
DISTRIBUTION. E. Himalayan region, SW. China.
Two species.
4. Ser. Uniflorae (Marquand) T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 14 (1985).
Sect. Frigida ser. Uniflorae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R.
hot. Gdns, Kew for 1937: 161 (1937). Type species: G.
filistyla Balf. f. & Forrest ex Marquand.
Flowers solitary, terminal; calyx-lobes narrowly elliptical or
triangular.
DISTRIBUTION. Himalayan region, SW. China.
Four species.
XI. Sect. Microsperma T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res. Harbin
5(4): 14 (1985). Type species: G. delavayi Franchet.
Annuals; capsule oblong; seed with honeycomb-like, hex-
agonal, simple, shallow pits.
DISTRIBUTION. Nepal, Bhutan, SW. China.
Three series, 10 species.
T.-N. HO&S.-W. LIU
1. Ser. Suborbisepalae (Marquand) T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 15 (1985).
Sect. Frigida ser. Suborbisepalae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf.
R. hot. Gdns, Kew for 1937: 160 (1937). Type species: G.
suborbisepala Marquand.
Leaves and calyx-lobes spathulate; flowers small; gynoecium
and stamens usually exserted from the corolla.
DISTRIBUTION. Nepal, Bhutan, SW. China.
Six species.
2. Ser. Tetramerae (Marquand) T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 15 (1985).
Sect. Frigida ser. Annuae subser. Tetramerae Marquand in
Bull. misc. Inf. R. hot. Gdns, Kew for 1937: 165 (1937).
Type species: G. lineolata Franchet.
Flowers 4-merous, medium-sized; calyx-lobes with strongly
keeled midribs which are decurrent below into strong wings.
DISTRIBUTION. China (Yunnan, Sichuan).
Two species.
3. Ser. Annuae (Marquand) T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res.
Harbin 5(4): 15 (1985).
Sect. Frigida ser. Annuae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R.
hot. Gdns, Kew for 1937: 165 (1937). Type species: G. picta
Franchet ex F. B. Forbes & Hemsley.
Flowers 5-merous, small; calyx-lobes linear or oblanceolate.
DISTRIBUTION. China (Yunnan, Sichuan).
Two species.
XII. Sect. Stenogyne Franchet in Bull. Soc. hot. Fr. 31: 375
(1884). Type species: G. primulaefolia Franchet.
Annuals, rarely perennials; flowers large or medium-sized;
calyx keeled or winged; plicae asymmetrical, extremely oblique;
style filiform, longer or slightly shorter than the ovary; seeds
usually with a minutely reticulate testa, triquetrous with three
winged edges, rarely unwinged or areolate.
DISTRIBUTION. E. Burma, SW., NW., N., C., and S. China,
Thailand.
Fourteen species.
XIII. Sect. Dolichocarpa T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res. Harbin 5
(4): 16 (1985). Type species: G. prostrata Haenke.
Varasia Philippi, Fl. atacam.: 35 (1860). Type species: V.
podocarpa Philippi.
Annuals; flowers small; plicae symmetrical, large; capsule
oblong, unwinged; seeds minutely reticulate, unwinged at
maturity, rarely winged when young.
DISTRIBUTION. Europe (E. Alps); Asia (W. Asia (Iran,
Afghanistan), Pamir-Himalayan region, SW. and NW. China,
U.S.S.R. (Caucasus, Arctic region, C. Asia, W. and E.
Siberia, Far East)); N., C., and S. America.
Twelve species.
XIV. Sect. Chondrophyllae Bunge in Nouv. Mem. Soc. imp.
Nat. Mosc. 1(7): 207, 231 (1829) (Changed to Chondrophylla
by most later authors). Lectotype species: G. aquatica L.
CLASSIFICATION OF GENTIAN A
Chondrophylla (Bunge) Nelson in Bull. Torrey hot. Club 31:
245 (1904).
Holubia A. & D. Love in An. Inst. hot. A. J. Cavanilles 32:
226 (1975), nom. illeg. (Art. 64.1), non Holubia Oliver
(1884). Type species: H. pyrenaica (L.) A. & D. Love.
Holubogentia A. & D. Love in Bot. Notiser. 131: 385 (1978),
based on Holubia A. & D. Love.
Annuals, rarely perennials; flowers small; plicae symmetrical,
large; capsule obovoid or ellipsoid-oblong, conspicuously
winged, the wing strong and broad at the apex but gradually
narrowed towards the base; seeds minutely reticulate.
DISTRIBUTION. Europe, Asia, America, Morocco, Australia.
Eleven series, 158 species.
1. Ser. Fimbriatae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R. hot. Gdns,
Kew for 1937: 169 (1937). Lectotype species: G. panthaica
Burk. The type designation of 'G. recurvata C. B . Clarke' by
Ho (1985) is incorrect (Art. 8) because Marquand's original
series circumscription (1937) did not include G. recurvata.
Leaves and calyx densely and minutely papillose; calyx-lobes
filiform-subulate; plicae usually fimbriate, rarely dentate.
DISTRIBUTION. C. and E. Himalayan region, N. Burma, SW.,
C., and S. China, Indonesia (Sumatra).
Twenty species.
2. Ser. Rubicundae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R. hot.
Gdns, Kew for 1937: 171 (1937). Type species: G. rubicunda
Franchet.
Calyx-lobes filiform; plicae entire or denticulate.
DISTRIBUTION. China (except N. and NE.), Philippines.
Ten species.
3. Ser. Linearifoliae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R. hot.
Gdns, Kew for 1937: 170 (1937). Type species: G. aristata
Maxim.
Cauline leaves long and very narrow, at least the uppermost
linear or subulate.
DISTRIBUTION. Europe (E. Pyrenees, Carpathians, SW.
Bulgaria); Asia (W. Asia (Turkey, Iran, Afghanistan), C.
and E. Himalayan region, SW., S., and NW. China,
U.S.S.R. (Caucasus)).
Fifteen species.
4. Ser. Orbiculatae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R. hot.
Gdns, Kew for 1937: 170 (1937). Type species: G. squarrosa
Ledeb.
Calyx-lobes recurved or patent, rarely erect, ovate or orbicular,
rarely lanceolate, contracted at the base.
DISTRIBUTION. Kashmir-Himalayan region, China, U.S.S.R.
(C. Asia, W. and E. Siberia, Far East), Mongolia, Korea,
Japan, Indian Peninsula, Sri Lanka, Indonesia; E. Australia.
Twenty species.
5. Ser. Humiles Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R. hot. Gdns,
Kew for 1937: 172 (1937). Lectotype species: G. leucomel-
aena Maxim, ex Kusn. The type designation of 'G. aquanca
L.' by Ho (1985) is incorrect (Art. 8) because Marquand's
original circumscription (1937) did not include this species.
183
Ser. Pubigerae Marquand in Bull. misc. Inf. R. hot. Gdns,
Kew for 1937: 168 (1937).
Stems ascending or decumbent, usually branched from the
base, without a conspicuous main stem, or rarely
unbranched; calyx-lobes erect, triangular or lanceolate.
DISTRIBUTION. Europe (Spain); Asia (W. Asia, Kashmir-
Himalayan region, Burma, China, U.S.S.R. (Caucasus, C.
Asia, W. and E. Siberia), N. Mongolia, Korea, Japan); N.
America (western part of Canada and the United States).
Thirty-three species.
6. Ser. Capitatae T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res. Harbin 5(4): 18
(1985). Type species: G. capitata Buch.-Ham. ex D. Don.
Stems simple, densely papillose, winged or angled and leaf-
less in the lower half; in the upper half much branched with
abbreviated internodes, numerous leaves and flowering
branches, all congested at the apex of the stem into a
subcapitate inflorescence.
DISTRIBUTION. Asia (Kashmir-Himalayan region, N. Burma,
SW. China, Indo-China); C. America (Mexico and
Guatemala); Africa (Morocco).
Sixteen species.
7. Ser. Fastigiatae T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res. Harbin 5(4): 18
(1985). Type species: G. intricata Marquand.
Stems fastigiately branched from the base or the middle, the
main stem very conspicuous, with lax, more or less corym-
bosely disposed branches.
DISTRIBUTION. Asia (W. Asia, Pamir-Himalayan region,
China, U.S.S.R. (C. Asia, W. and E. Siberia, Far East),
Mongolia, Korea, Japan, Indonesia (Sumatra)); western part
of N. America.
Twenty-four species.
8. Ser. Napuliferae T.N. Ho in Bull. hot. Res. Harbin 5(4): 18
(1985). Type species: G. napulifera Franchet.
Perennials, with slightly fleshy, fusiform roots; leaves
herbaceous.
DISTRIBUTION. Bhutan, E. India (Assam), SW., C., and S.
China, Thailand, Vietnam.
Three species.
9. Ser. Coriaceae T.N. Ho, ser. nov. Type species: G.
cruttwellii H. Smith.
Herba perennis, radicibus fibrosis; folia coriacea.
DISTRIBUTION. S. China (Taiwan), Philippines, Sabah, New
Guinea.
Thirteen species.
10. Ser. Piasezkianae T.N. Ho in Bull. bot. Res. Harbin 5(4):
18 (1985). Type species: G. piasezkii Maxim.
Calyx-lobes with keeled midribs which are decurrent below
into conspicuous wings; corolla hypocrateriform; capsule
narrowly elliptical, attenuate or obtuse at the apex.
DISTRIBUTION. China (N. Sichuan, Gansu, Shaanxi).
Three species.
184
T.-N. HO&S.-W. LIU
11. Ser. Grandiflorae Grossh. ex T.N. Ho, ser. nov. Type
species: G. grandiflora Laxm.
Ser. Grandiflorae Grossh. in V. Komarov, Fl. URSS 18: 572
(1952), nom. inval. (Art. 36.1).
Herba perennis; flores grandi, 40-55 mm longi; capsula
anguste elliptica, apice attenuata vel obtusa.
DISTRIBUTION. U.S.S.R. (W. and E. Siberia, C. Asia),
Mongolia.
One species.
XV. Sect. Fimbricorona T.N. Ho, nom. nov.
Sect. Eurythalia (Borkh.) Griseb. in Getting, gel. Anz. for
1840 (2): 815 (1840), nom. illeg. (Art. 64.1), non Bunge
(1829). Lectotype species: G. coronata Royle.
Annuals; corolla bearing a corona of multicellular hairs in the
throat; plicae well-developed; capsule obovate, rounded at
the apex, winged, the wing strong and broad at the apex but
gradually narrowed towards the base of the capsule; seeds
minutely reticulate.
DISTRIBUTION. Kashmir-Himalayan region, mountains of
SW. China.
Four species.
GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION
Gentiana is a subcosmopolitan genus. It is distributed widely
in Europe and the temperate zone of Asia and N. America,
but a few species extend northwards to the Arctic region
(arctic Siberia, Iceland and to 73 N in Greenland), south-
wards to C. and S. America (the southernmost to Santa Cruz
(c. 49 58'S, 69W), Argentina), through S. Asia to the South
Tableland (c. 35 58'S, 149 25'E) of Australia, and from SW.
Europe to Djebel Toubkal in C. Morocco.
There are 14 sections in Asia, eight in Europe, and six in
America, comprising 93.3%, 53.3%, and 40% respectively of
the world total, while there are 312 species in Asia, 27 in
Europe, and 35 in America, comprising 86.4%, 7.5%, and
9.7% respectively of the world total,
In Asia (Table 1) sect. Ciminalis is entirely absent; sect.
Gentiana and sect. Calathianae contain only one or two
species in this area and are restricted to W. Asia, with a few
subspecies scattered as far as Lake Baikal; sect. Pneumonanthe
also has few (only 12) here. Conversely, the other 11 sections
contain their highest numbers of species in Asia, i.e. Otophora
12 species in Asia/ 12 species in the world, Cruciata 21/21,
Monopodiae 37/37, Frigida 16/18, Phyllocalyx 1/1, Isomeria
18/18, Microsperma 10/10, Stenogyne 14/14, Dolichocarpa 10/
12, Chondrophyllae 154/158, and Fimbricorona 4/4. More-
over, of these 11 sections, six (Otophora, Monopodiae,
Phyllocalyx, Microsperma, Stenogyne, and Fimbricorona) are
endemic to Asia. In respect of species, of the 312 species 299
are endemic to Asia, 95.8% of the total for Asia, and only 13
are common to Asia and Europe or America. It is clear that
Asia is the major centre for Gentiana with the greatest
number of species as well as endemics. The highest con-
centration of these occurs in the mountains of SW. China
(NW. Yunnan, W. Sichuan, and SE. Tibet) and in the NE.
Burma area, the square between 25-34 N and 91-105 E. In
this area there are 1 1 sections and 190 species, of which 98 are
endemic to the mountains of SW. China and the NE. Burma
area; thus three quarters of all the sections and half the
species of the world occur in this small area, indicating that it
is a major centre of diversity and endemism of Gentiana. In
addition, 10 sections and 61 species (13 of which are local
Table 1 The numbers of species of Gentiana in different regions.
Sections
> o
n.
o
8
I
o
6
Crucial
G.
O
03
T3
Gentia
o
13 r"!
(U >>
'
5
"
U
cfl
C
E
ij
(U
o
89
Micros
eo .c
o u
c